The Supreme Court of Canada has rejected Iris Technologies’ attempt to challenge tax assessments through declarations in the Federal Court, holding that its complaints could not sustain a separate judicial review proceeding.

In Iris Technologies Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), 2024 SCC 24, all seven judges dismissed the telecommunications company’s appeal with costs on June 28, 2024. They divided four to three on their reasoning about the boundary between the Federal Court and the Tax Court of Canada.

The ruling left Iris to pursue its challenge to the assessments through the tax appeal system. It did not decide whether the disputed tax and penalties were properly owing or establish that the minister had acted unfairly.

Dispute followed withheld GST refunds

The case arose from an audit of Iris’s GST returns. After an earlier audit produced no adjustments to its refunds, the Minister of National Revenue began another audit and withheld further refunds. Iris sought an order compelling their release and applied for interim relief.

Before the interim application was heard, the minister issued assessments and reassessments for 2019 reporting periods. They disallowed $98 million in input tax credits and imposed more than $24 million in gross negligence penalties, with interest. Those were the minister’s assessed amounts, not sums awarded by the Supreme Court.

Iris later sought three declarations from the Federal Court. It alleged that the minister had denied it notice and an opportunity to respond to proposed adjustments, issued assessments without an evidentiary foundation, and acted for the improper purpose of depriving the Federal Court of jurisdiction in its related proceeding.

The Attorney General sought to strike the application before a hearing on its merits. A Federal Court prothonotary refused, and a Federal Court judge upheld that decision, viewing the application as a challenge to the minister’s conduct. The Federal Court of Appeal disagreed, finding that the application was essentially a collateral challenge to the assessments and sought declarations with no practical effect.

The Supreme Court upheld that result. The threshold for striking such an application is high: factual allegations are assumed true, and the application must have no possibility of success. That assumption does not establish the allegations as findings.

Tax appeals could address the first two complaints

Writing for the four-judge majority, Justice Nicholas Kasirer said the application’s essential nature was an attack on the assessments denying Iris’s claimed refunds.

The Excise Tax Act provides a route to the Tax Court to challenge assessments after the objection process. Section 18.5 of the Federal Courts Act excludes Federal Court judicial review to the extent Parliament has expressly provided for an appeal.

Iris’s procedural fairness complaint concerned the timing of the assessments and its alleged inability to respond before they were issued. An appeal to the Tax Court would give Iris an opportunity to respond to the adjustments. On the allegations advanced, that was an adequate remedy capable of curing the problem.

The complaint that the assessments lacked supporting evidence belonged in the same forum. The Tax Court determines tax liability afresh on a full evidentiary record; its role includes deciding whether the assessment is supported by the facts and law.

That did not give the Tax Court a general power to set aside an otherwise correct assessment because of misconduct in the process. The distinction was between resolving the amount properly owing and supervising government conduct that could support a separate administrative law claim.

Improper-purpose allegation lacked supporting facts

The majority accepted that an allegation of improper purpose can, in appropriate circumstances, support judicial review in the Federal Court. The issuance of an assessment does not automatically eliminate that court’s jurisdiction over the minister’s conduct.

But Iris had not pleaded facts capable of supporting its allegation. It identified no particular motive or conduct beyond saying that the assessments were issued to deprive the Federal Court of jurisdiction in the related case.

Kasirer distinguished the minister’s statutory duty to assess tax from a discretionary decision. In assessing Iris’s net tax, the minister had to apply the Excise Tax Act to the facts; the outcome was dictated by the legislation. Fulfilling that responsibility could not itself establish an improper motive.

The distinction also explained the companion decision in Dow Chemical Canada ULC v. Canada, 2024 SCC 23. There, the majority held that a challenge to a discretionary refusal of a downward transfer pricing adjustment belonged in the Federal Court. That discretion was separate from the assessment, even though its exercise could affect tax liability.

Three judges preferred a broader assessment-focused inquiry

Justice Suzanne Côté, joined by Justices Andromache Karakatsanis and Malcolm Rowe, agreed Iris’s application should be struck but approached the jurisdictional issue differently.

She emphasized a practical reading of the entire claim and whether an appeal to the Tax Court was available, adequate and effective. Judicial review should remain a last resort where the statutory tax appeal could provide the relief sought.

The first two complaints could be addressed through that appeal. Côté also considered the improper-purpose allegation inseparable from the correctness of the assessments and premature: Iris could not succeed on that claim in the Federal Court without first establishing in the Tax Court that the assessments were incorrect.

Her approach reflected her dissent in Dow Chemical, where she considered the discretionary decision sufficiently connected to the assessment to fall within the tax appeal. In Iris, however, both groups reached the same outcome.

Declarations would not resolve a live dispute

An independent ground also defeated Iris’s application: the proposed declarations would have no practical utility.

A declaration must settle a live controversy connected to the parties’ rights. Iris’s suggestion that the declarations could affect the minister’s ongoing dealings with it, including an emergency wage subsidy application, did not establish that utility.

The Federal Court could not vary or vacate the assessments. Even if Iris obtained the declarations, it would still have to pursue a tax appeal to change the assessed liability. Both sets of reasons concluded that declarations detached from a practical legal result could not be granted in this case.

Source: Supreme Court of Canada, 2024 SCC 24.