
Tax Court finds retail merchandisers were independent contractors for EI and CPP
Project instructions and team supervision did not outweigh the workers’ freedom to accept assignments and work for other businesses.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Prince Edward Island.
46 stories
Project instructions and team supervision did not outweigh the workers’ freedom to accept assignments and work for other businesses.

A municipal complaint process bypassed required safeguards, and a later vote could not bar a former councillor from future office. The report does not decide whether the…

The Rental Office resumed a tenant’s deposit claim months after closing the file, without a decision reopening it. The appeal did not decide who was entitled to the deposit.

Commission allowed $149.50 for TV-mount repairs but removed a $200 countertop award, with a missing move-in report limiting proof of other damage.

Knowledge of a roommate’s occupancy and his name on rent receipts did not establish a tenancy agreement on the evidence. The Commission left the underlying compensation claims…

Commission added unpaid rent and painting costs, leaving a $1,411.13 balance after accounting for the tenants’ $4,097.49 entitlement.

Below-market rent, repair spending and plans to renovate after vacancy did not justify setting aside the order; the landlord was given one month from the decision to finish the…

A 9:03 p.m. filing on the deadline was treated as arriving the next day, triggering double repayment of the $2,500 deposit plus interest.

The presiding commissioner’s decision leaves Bhaskar responsible for repayment, while a dissent says prospective tenants should not bear the risk of undisclosed agency limits.

The tribunal found that intent to cause damage was not required, overturning an order that would have let the tenants return after repairs.

The September ruling balanced a serious conviction against a detailed release plan and arguable grounds; it did not decide the appeal’s merits.

IRAC partly allowed two tenants’ appeals, awarding $700 each for cumulative security, maintenance and communication failures despite eventual repairs.

The appeal court rejected a challenge brought in the wrong province without deciding the underlying seed-potato contract dispute.

The developer and province amended the transfer arrangement before the final lot sold, when the owners’ claimed benefit was still contingent.

The commission found two days’ notice insufficient to end a fixed-term tenancy, but held that the separate rent claim did not cure the landlords’ missed security-deposit deadline.

The commission said it could not waive statutory timelines and dismissed the appeal without deciding whether the tenant had breached the lease’s cannabis provisions.

The privacy commissioner reasonably declined two inquiries into planned disclosure of records concerning the business, the court found.

The order covers the Kinross-to-Vernon River replacement, not Maritime Electric’s full $102.6-million capital request.

A sole shareholder received permission to represent C3stones, while a stay failed for lack of evidence of irreparable harm.

The court found flaws in the board’s appeal analysis and treatment of commissions, but did not declare the employer compliant.