
CRA must reconsider recovery-benefit calculation for newcomer cook
Federal appeal court rejects unexplained use of a full-year income divisor but leaves benefit entitlement for a fresh CRA decision.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Federal.
193 stories
Federal appeal court rejects unexplained use of a full-year income divisor but leaves benefit entitlement for a fresh CRA decision.

Tax Court looks beyond legal title to assets and finds Ontario’s effective control decisive for CEWS eligibility.

Global settlement offer and disputed cross-examination did not justify punitive treatment after three corporate tax appeals were quashed.

Court finds the program’s prescribed method reasonable despite the farm’s claim that two fiscal year-ends distorted its results.

Appeal court upholds expungement and costs, clarifying that opposition and expungement share one distinctiveness test.

Federal Court of Appeal rejects the territory’s challenge after formal discontinuance, with costs fixed at $4,000.

Federal Court of Appeal rejects the bank’s rebate argument while declining to impose a universal definition of gift certificate.

Tax Court says intervention rule applies to an appeal or reference, not a motion inside one, leaving the underlying tax dispute undecided.

The mixed ruling separates accounting errors, reassessment powers and the higher threshold for gross-negligence penalties.

Missing background history left the application incomplete. The judge distinguished its return from a refusal on the merits and preserved a qualification about reviewability.

The Commission considered whether the union caused the withdrawal but overlooked the paralegal’s advice. The court ordered reconsideration without deciding an incompetence…

An officer did not explain why savings, wage records and proof of qualifying employment fell short. A father’s work permit and his son’s visitor visa must be reconsidered.

The Federal Court rejected challenges to the driver’s knowledge, interpretation of his interview and the records linking seized material to laboratory testing.

The court found two credibility assessments reasonable, including the treatment of border statements and a separate threat absent from the written claim.

The court found no genuine issue for trial on the permit-related tort claims and struck the remaining claims, while leaving IRCC’s duty of care undecided.

Former executive’s tax appeals fail because litigation-related housing costs did not meet employment-expense requirements.

National Defence had already refused the request. The court found a later letter repeated it, while leaving other available challenges to the refusal open.

The minister must decide a New Brunswick nominee’s permanent residence application within 90 days. A proposed appeal question on costs was left uncertified.

The claim lacked an independent basis for damages and repeated a challenge already dismissed for delay. The court did not decide the proposed CERB and CRB income interpretation.

Tax Court upheld a denied $340,000 capital loss and two $170,000 income inclusions while stressing that a bad loan is not automatically a sham.