
The Federal Court has dismissed a Canadian citizen’s challenge to the return of her incomplete parents’ sponsorship application, finding there was no reviewable decision because immigration officials had declined to process it rather than refused it on the merits.
In Dang v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1402, Justice Ekaterina Tsimberis found that gaps remained in required background and employment records even after Himani Dang supplied corrected documents. The November 13 judgment left the return of her 2024 Parents and Grandparents Program application in place without deciding her complaints about procedural fairness or the reasonableness of the officer’s assessment.
Corrected documents still had gaps
Dang applied to sponsor her parents for permanent residence through the family-class program. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada initially told her that the submission lacked valid passports, proof of a family relationship and complete background documents. It gave her 30 days to provide the missing and corrected material.
Before the deadline, Dang submitted passports, relationship evidence, a new resume and an amended Background/Declaration Form. Nevertheless, an April 7, 2025 letter returned the application because gaps remained in the principal applicant’s personal, address and employment history. The letter said Dang would not receive another invitation to apply under the 2024 program.
Dang argued that she should have received another opportunity to correct the application and that the officer had failed to grapple with the new material she submitted in March 2025. The minister answered that returning an incomplete application was not a refusal of the sponsorship application and therefore was not a decision available for judicial review.
The judge rejected Dang’s contention that her revised submission was complete. The applicable checklist, forms and earlier IRCC letter required an account of all relevant periods. Because the principal applicant had been retired for more than 10 years, the required personal and work history extended back to age 18. The amended form and resume still failed to supply that history completely.
Returning an application was distinct from refusing it
The court relied on the statutory distinction between processing an application and returning it for non-compliance. Section 87.3(5) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act says that retaining, returning or otherwise disposing of an application does not constitute a decision to deny the requested visa or status.
The regulations require applications to include the necessary information and documents. Section 12 requires an application to be returned when the requirements of sections 10 and 11 are not met. Tsimberis also relied on earlier decisions treating such returns as non-reviewable, including an appeal ruling that an incomplete submission is not an application within the meaning of the legislation.
That conclusion disposed of Dang’s case. The judge did not go on to decide whether a second chance was required by procedural fairness or whether the officer’s treatment of her materials was reasonable.
A qualification to the ruling
The reasons did not declare every returned application immune from review. Dang had not sought reconsideration or provided specific submissions establishing a reviewable decision. The minister’s lawyer conceded that a rejection might not be categorically immune if she had requested reconsideration with a completed application, or if the returned application had actually been complete. Neither situation was established here.
Tsimberis acknowledged the difficulty caused by the loss of another invitation under the 2024 program. That consequence did not change the character of the refusal to process the incomplete submission. The judge noted the letter’s suggestion that a super visa might be available; the ruling did not grant one or determine eligibility.
The application for judicial review was dismissed, and no question was certified.
Source: Dang v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1402.



