
The Federal Court has upheld the refusal of a family’s refugee claim, finding that the Refugee Protection Division reasonably relied on significant differences between their initial accounts and the threats they later described.
In Campos Munoz v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1396, Justice L. Saint-Fleur dismissed the family’s judicial-review application without costs. The November 13 judgment left the refusal in place; it did not make a removal order.
The court addressed two distinct credibility findings: the principal applicant’s failure to mention alleged threats linked to her stepfather when first explaining her fear of returning to Venezuela, and her partner’s omission of a separate alleged threat to his family from his written claim.
Initial account differed from the alleged police threat
The adult applicants were Venezuelan citizens who had lived in Colombia before seeking protection in Canada with their child. They alleged that the principal applicant’s stepfather, a former police officer, had incriminating information about senior officers who were threatening the family.
The Refugee Protection Division rejected the claim in February 2025. At her port-of-entry interview, the principal applicant had said she feared the Venezuelan government because people lacked access to necessities such as food. Her statutory declaration likewise referred to economic hardship. Her later Basis of Claim form and hearing testimony instead described fears arising from her stepfather’s alleged enemies.
She explained that she had withheld the police-related account because she feared being denied entry if she reported a dispute with a police officer. The division did not accept that explanation. It considered the difference substantial rather than a minor omission and found that she understood the need to answer candidly.
Before the Federal Court, the applicants argued that the division had relied too heavily on border statements. They emphasized that refugees may have good reasons to distrust authority and maintained that their hearing testimony and written refugee claims were consistent. They also said corroborating documents had not been properly assessed.
The court found the credibility assessment reasonable. The division had given the principal applicant an opportunity to explain the discrepancy. Economic hardship was a significant part of her initial account, and the later police-enemy narrative was materially different.
The judgment does not treat every omission at a border interview as fatal. The division acknowledged the caution surrounding such notes, but the court accepted its assessment of the particular inconsistencies in this record.
Corroboration did not resolve the problem
The division had considered photographs said to show the stepfather’s enemies and a letter from the principal applicant’s brother. It found that the photographs could depict anyone and did not independently establish the alleged targeting. It also found the family letter insufficient to overcome the serious credibility concerns.
Justice Saint-Fleur rejected the argument that this evidence had gone unexamined. The division had engaged with both the photographs and the letter and reasonably concluded that they did not overcome its adverse finding.
A separate threat was missing from the written claim
The partner advanced another basis for fearing Venezuela: his sister had allegedly uncovered corruption while working at a municipal office and confronted her superiors before fleeing the country.
He added that account to his Basis of Claim form only days before the refugee hearing. At the hearing, he further alleged that his sister had been warned that her family would be harmed if the corruption became known. That threat had not appeared in his written claim. Asked why, he said he did not know.
The court found that the division could draw a negative inference when important details emerged at a hearing but were absent from the written account. It reasonably concluded that the alleged incident and resulting risk had not been established by sufficiently credible and trustworthy evidence.
The division had also rejected a fear of persecution as failed refugee claimants, finding that the identified risk primarily concerned vocal opponents of Venezuela’s government rather than these applicants. The court’s analysis focused on the challenged credibility findings.
Finding the division’s reasoning coherent and justified by the evidence and law, the court dismissed the application. Neither party proposed a question for certification, and the judge found none arose.
Source: Campos Munoz v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC 1396.



