
Prison stabbing claim dismissed despite error releasing attacker from cell
The B.C. Supreme Court found that an unchecked appointment claim enabled the attack, but the harm was not reasonably foreseeable.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Personal Injury.
28 stories
The B.C. Supreme Court found that an unchecked appointment claim enabled the attack, but the harm was not reasonably foreseeable.

The tribunal mistook $362,880 in family invoices for professional care and overlooked an argument about how those expenses could qualify for coverage.

Darcy Baragar argued that his award should reflect shipyard wages through retirement. His work history and interest in retraining led the trial judge to value the loss differently.

The driver had already brought the city into the case. The plaintiff sought to sue it directly after her lawyers noticed the driver’s $200,000 insurance limit.

The court found substantial success despite unsuccessful appeal grounds and an increase smaller than the plaintiff had sought.

The appeal court upholds dismissal of a late injury claim while clarifying that acknowledgment of liability turns on the wording and context of the communication.

Both appeals were dismissed, but four judges found the patient's injuries were not too remote from her obstetrician's negligence.

The court found the filing period extended through the next open day; the collision claim’s negligence and damages issues remain undecided.

Bennett ruling leaves motorcycle ownership and the effect of alleged misrepresentations for a later summary judgment motion.

Three agreements create a pooled compensation fund, with eligibility limits, variable awards and substantial approved deductions.

Residents may pursue their broader exposure-based claim after the court ruled that disputed knowledge of the alleged harm must be assessed on the merits.

The judge distinguished the mixed gravel and soil from a hard-surface slipping hazard and did not reach the defendants’ inspection regime.

The court dismissed SGI’s bid to strike the claim and awarded $2,000 in costs, without deciding whether the terminated benefits should be restored.

The court upheld the removal of a son’s punitive-damages claims from a wrongful-death lawsuit, finding the statute compensates survivors rather than punishes defendants.

The appeal court upheld findings that the accident temporarily worsened a pre-existing condition, without treating continuing symptoms as proof of continuing accident-related…

The court found appropriate consent and surgical care, and rejected an inference of technical error from the patient’s serious complications.

Definity wins mileage appeal on the evidence, without establishing a universal rate for treatment-related travel.

Planned impeachment and an authentication-only witness did not waive privilege; admissibility and related disclosure remained for the trial judge.

