
A Nova Scotia judge has dismissed a woman's claim over a playground fall that broke her leg, finding that scattered gravel on exposed dirt did not establish an actionable hazard in the circumstances.
In Sabiston v. Halifax Regional Centre for Education, 2026 NSSC 274, Justice John A. Keith dismissed Tara-Rose Sabiston's action against the regional education centre and Halifax Regional Municipality. The parties had agreed on the amount of damages, leaving liability for trial. The August 20 decision did not disclose that amount or award it.
The ruling turned on what made the ground give way and whether the defendants had failed to take reasonable care. It distinguished small quantities of mixed gravel on soil from pea stone scattered across a hard surface such as asphalt. The court did not proceed to assess the defendants' inspection and maintenance system because Sabiston had not established the necessary initial case of negligence.
What the ground and photographs showed
Sabiston fell in June 2017 while leaving the playground area of an elementary school to reach nearby benches. She stepped over its wooden border, placing her right foot approximately six inches below the top of the cribbing. As she moved forward, the ground under that foot gave way. Her footwear was appropriate, and she did not allege that the wooden border was itself a tripping hazard.
The playground contained a twelve-inch layer of small, smooth pea stone intended to absorb the impact of falls from equipment. The material complied with the applicable playground safety standard. Outside the playground, other gravel was larger, rougher and more irregular. Heavy pedestrian traffic had worn away sod near the exit, exposing dirt, and had moved both types of gravel around the area.
A photograph taken by Sabiston's mother six days after the accident provided the most contemporaneous view. Keith found that most gravel had accumulated farther down the slope, away from the spot where Sabiston placed her foot. That spot was mainly exposed dirt with a smaller scattering of mixed gravel, some embedded in the soil.
Sabiston's playground-safety expert had not visited the site, did not know the amount of loose stone present on the accident date and had not reviewed that photograph. He relied instead on photographs taken months later. On the ground's condition, Keith preferred the evidence of defence witnesses who described both pea stone and larger gravel in the area.
Why the hard-surface comparison failed
The evidence established that pea stone can create a slipping hazard on asphalt or concrete. Municipal workers sometimes swept it from those surfaces. They did not treat gravel on grass or exposed dirt the same way.
Sabiston's case focused on pea stone that had escaped the playground. But Keith found no evidentiary basis to equate the soil where she fell with asphalt. Although the day was warm and sunny and foot traffic may have compacted the ground, the degree of compaction was unknown. Some stones had become embedded, showing that the ground remained softer than a hard paved surface.
The judge did not find that rolling pea stone, or excessive layers of stones rolling against each other, caused the accident. Instead, Sabiston's forward momentum caused the dry dirt and scattered mixed gravel beneath her foot to give way. The playground standard did not apply to the spot outside the play area where she fell.
Reasonable care, assessed in context
Nova Scotia's Occupiers' Liability Act requires reasonable care to keep visitors reasonably safe. It does not make an occupier an insurer against every injury. The plaintiff had to establish a hazardous condition, its connection to the accident and a failure by the occupier to meet the statutory standard.
Keith found the small scattering of gravel on exposed dirt ordinary in this heavily used outdoor setting. Many adults had taken the same natural route to the benches safely over the years. There were no known prior adult falls or evidence of earlier injury-producing falls, despite substantial traffic. Nothing showed that the defendants knew or should have known of a dangerous condition requiring correction.
The court also considered the Act's specific contextual factors. The defendants knew children and adults would use the grounds. Sabiston was a frequent visitor familiar with the playground layout, change in grade and route. The visible conditions did not create a risk against which additional protection could reasonably be expected on this evidence.
Requiring the defendants to prevent every movement of gravel or eliminate every outdoor surface irregularity would impose perfection rather than reasonable care, Keith concluded. That was a finding about these conditions, not a rule that gravel can never be hazardous.
The court acknowledged the seriousness of Sabiston's injury but found no actionable hazard, breach of duty or negligent act or omission causing it. The action was dismissed without advancing to the further question of whether the defendants maintained an adequate inspection, maintenance and monitoring regime.



