An Alberta judge refused to order advance production of a private investigator’s surveillance file in a personal injury lawsuit, finding that the defendant had not waived litigation privilege by planning to use the material to challenge the plaintiff’s credibility at trial.

In Blackstone v. Chen, 2026 ABKB 69, Justice O.P. Malik distinguished a proposed impeachment use from reliance on surveillance as substantive evidence. The February 3 case-management ruling left admissibility, use of the material and possible disclosure of related records to the trial judge.

Sara Blackstone was injured in a pedestrian motor vehicle accident and claimed damages for lost income and earning capacity. Liability was not disputed. Zhong Yuan Chen retained an investigation firm to conduct surveillance, and a report was listed among privileged records in a draft affidavit of records.

Blackstone sought the entire surveillance file, including reports, raw footage, photographs and other surveillance material. She argued that privilege had been waived when the defence said it intended to use the report at trial and identified the investigator as a witness.

Chen maintained that the report was intended only to impeach credibility. The investigator was listed as a potential witness solely to answer questions about authenticity, not to give substantive evidence about the surveillance.

Planned impeachment did not itself waive privilege

The court relied on Alberta authorities permitting a party to maintain privilege over a record intended exclusively for impeachment, provided the record’s existence has been disclosed. Blackstone had not supplied contrary authority displacing that principle.

That distinction matters: listing a privileged report gives notice that it exists without necessarily requiring production of its contents before trial. But maintaining privilege before trial does not guarantee that the document can later be admitted. Malik expressly reserved that decision.

The judgment’s discussion of earlier cases involving dishonest plaintiffs was not a finding that Blackstone had been dishonest. This ruling resolved a disclosure dispute, not her credibility or the value of her injury claim.

Three reasons the fairness argument failed

Blackstone also relied on authorities addressing fairness and consistency. Those cases recognize that reliance on evidence, or selective disclosure that presents an incomplete picture, can require broader production despite a privilege claim.

Malik identified three differences between those authorities and this case.

First, the investigator’s proposed role was limited. In an earlier case Blackstone cited, an investigator was to testify as a factual witness about surveillance activities and observations. Here, the proposed testimony concerned only the report’s authenticity. Listing that witness did not establish the same substantive reliance.

Second, the surveillance did not appear to inform any expert evidence Chen intended to introduce. Other decisions involved privileged material underlying expert assumptions, conclusions or reassessments of an injury. That connection could engage fairness and consistency because a party was relying on an opinion shaped by the withheld material. The necessary connection was absent on this record.

Third, Chen had not selectively disclosed favourable portions while withholding the rest. Privilege was claimed over the entire file, and no part had been disclosed to Blackstone or to the defence experts. The concern about creating an unfair or inaccurate impression through selective waiver therefore did not justify advance production here.

The judge nevertheless left an important question open. If the report were admitted to impeach Blackstone at trial, the trial judge would decide whether other parts of the file dealing with the same particular subject matter also had to be disclosed.

A narrow pretrial ruling

The application was dismissed, with costs reserved for assessment by the trial judge. The reasons recorded a trial scheduled to start on March 4, 2026; they do not establish what subsequently happened at trial or whether surveillance was admitted.

The result preserves the claimed privilege at the pretrial stage on these facts. It does not authorize unrestricted use of undisclosed surveillance, determine damages or resolve the plaintiff’s credibility.

Source: Blackstone v. Chen, 2026 ABKB 69.