
The Tax Court of Canada has upheld reassessments of two Ottawa-area businesspeople and a related company after finding that a purported $340,000 intercompany debt was a sham, not a genuine refinancing arrangement.
In Ielo v. The King, 2026 TCC 195, issued November 9, Justice John A. Sorensen found that the taxpayers knew the documented debt was not real. That finding supported reassessing their 2011 taxation year beyond the normal limitation period.
The court dismissed the appeals of Bruno Ielo, Giovanni Ielo and 2229798 Ontario Inc. with costs. It upheld denial of the company’s $340,000 capital loss and income inclusions of $170,000 for each brother. Those amounts are tax adjustments, not a statement of the tax ultimately payable.
Bank borrowing did not establish the disputed debt
The brothers owned Astral Fitness & Health Club Inc., which operated a gym in Stittsville. Another company, 2229798, owned the building. Astral owed the brothers shareholder loans but lacked the funds to repay them.
Scotiabank declined to lend to Astral. It instead advanced $340,000 to the property-owning company, secured against the building and repayable from its planned sale. The bank restricted how the proceeds could be used.
On May 2, 2011, 2229798 paid $170,000 directly to each brother. No funds were advanced to Astral. A promissory note and corporate resolutions purported to establish a corresponding debt from Astral to 2229798. Five days later, the gym closed.
The taxpayers maintained that this was a legitimate refinancing and that they expected Astral to remain viable and repay the debt. Sorensen rejected that account after considering the evidence together, rather than treating any single troubling fact as decisive.
Sham finding rested on the whole record
The gym was losing money, behind on rent and facing competition from a local community centre. The court also considered the urgency of paying the loan proceeds to the brothers, evidence that the building’s purchaser wanted the gym’s space, and the lack of a supported plan to relocate or downsize.
The account of a sudden decision to close was difficult to reconcile with the principals’ usual careful, consultative approach to business. The company did not seek to enforce the purported debt. A late, insufficient interest payment made from an account opened by one brother did not persuade the court that the obligation was genuine.
Explanations given to the Canada Revenue Agency during the audit also conflicted with aspects of the trial evidence. Sorensen considered those inconsistencies without accepting every statement in the audit correspondence as true.
The legal distinction mattered. A sham involves knowingly presenting rights and obligations differently from what the parties know them to be. It is not established merely because a transaction lacks an obvious business purpose, seeks a tax advantage or proves financially unwise. Nor does the tax-law finding itself amount to a criminal conviction or a finding of tortious deceit.
Consequences for the reassessments
Because the documented obligation was not real, the company had no debt on which to claim the capital loss. The brothers were officers of 2229798, and their payments were taxable benefits under paragraph 6(1)(a) of the Income Tax Act, rather than tax-free repayments of Astral’s shareholder loans.
The sham finding also established wilful misrepresentation in the returns, permitting the otherwise late reassessments. Reliance on advisers did not change the court’s conclusion about the taxpayers’ own knowledge.
A further argument that the arrangement replaced the old creditor relationship with a new one also failed. Recharacterizing the paperwork as a novation could not make an unreal obligation genuine.
Sorensen expressly limited the ruling to its facts. Lending to a distressed related company can create a genuine debt even if the decision is unwise; a bad loan is not automatically a sham. The amount of costs remained to be agreed or determined under the court’s directions.



