Hyota Farms has lost its challenge to the refusal of 2019 AgriStability benefits, after the Federal Court of Appeal found it reasonable to apply the program’s prescribed calculations despite the company’s claim that fluctuating hog prices distorted the result.

In Hyota Farms Ltd. v. Canada, 2026 FCA 178, the court dismissed the appeal with costs. Justice George Locke delivered the court’s reasons from the bench in Winnipeg on October 27, 2026. The reasons do not specify a costs amount.

Two year-ends complicated the calculation

Hyota indicated in 2019 that it intended to participate in AgriStability and applied for benefits in 2020. A change in its fiscal year-end meant it had two year-ends in 2019: June 30 and December 28.

The program guidelines expressly address a fiscal period shorter than 12 months. They require its financial information to be combined with preceding statements until at least 12 months are available, then prorated to a 12-month period.

The Farm Income Programs Directorate applied that approach and the guidelines’ hybrid inventory adjustment. It concluded that Hyota was not eligible for benefits and communicated its decision on March 11, 2024.

Hyota did not dispute that the directorate used the prescribed approach. Instead, it argued that hog prices were high in June and low in December, so the calculations made its year look more successful than it actually was. The company said rigidly applying the guidelines ignored economic reality and improperly restricted the decision-maker’s discretion.

The guidelines were part of the governing framework

The Federal Court rejected Hyota’s judicial-review application in 2025 FC 304. On appeal, the parties agreed that reasonableness was the appropriate review standard. The appeal court examined the directorate’s decision directly to decide whether the Federal Court had applied that standard correctly.

The court concluded that the refusal was reasonable. The Farm Income Protection Act authorizes agreements establishing income-stabilization programs and requires those agreements to address eligibility and income calculations. The resulting Canadian Agricultural Partnership agreement expressly provides for program guidelines and requires administrators to follow them.

Those guidelines specifically anticipated Hyota’s changed year-end. Because they arose from an intergovernmental agreement grounded in federal legislation, the directorate’s ability to depart from them was significantly constrained. The court found no authority for a different calculation simply because Hyota claimed the prescribed method disadvantaged it.

The judges also rejected Hyota’s argument that the guidelines permitted its proposed method. An earlier case, Mac Berry Farms Limited v. Canada (Agriculture and Agri-Food), 2022 FC 264, did not assist: that decision concerned inadequate reasons, whereas Hyota accepted that the directorate’s reasons here were adequate.

The ruling leaves the denial of Hyota’s 2019 benefits in place. Its practical significance is tied to this program’s statutory and contractual framework, not a general rule that every administrative guideline is binding or that economic hardship can never matter.