
The Federal Court has dismissed a damages action arising from a misspelled work permit and an allegedly delayed Ontario accident settlement, finding no genuine issue for trial on the immigration-related tort claims and no basis for the remaining pleadings to proceed.
In Thomas v. Canada (Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship), 2026 FC 1403, Justice Angus Grant granted summary judgment on negligence and misfeasance in public office claims concerning the permit. He struck the rest of the action without leave to amend, including claims involving provincial officials and alleged rights violations.
Jesso Ben Thomas sought damages that varied between $20 million and $44 million. The November 13 decision did not determine whether Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada owed him a duty of care. The judge expressly left that question open, finding the claim failed on other grounds.
A spelling error and the evidence of correction
Thomas applied for a post-graduation work permit in January 2021. At the top of his application, he spelled his first name as “Jesson,” although the government did not dispute that other portions of the application and identity documents may have used the correct spelling. IRCC reproduced the error when issuing a three-year permit in March 2021.
The record showed a request to correct the name in December 2021, roughly nine months later. Thomas did not indicate urgency on the amendment form. IRCC reissued the permit with the correct name, effective February 16, 2022.
Thomas alleged that officials had ignored 17 correction requests, producing a 547-day delay. Grant found those allegations unsupported by the records and noted that 547 days had not even elapsed between the original permit and its correction.
Thomas also attributed lost employment opportunities and wider financial and personal hardship to the typo. Although he submitted material about job opportunities, the judge found no correspondence showing that an employer had refused him because of the discrepancy.
Three distinct reasons the tort claims failed
On summary judgment, the question was whether there was a genuine issue requiring trial. The defendants had to demonstrate that the claim did not warrant a future trial, while Thomas had to put his best available case forward in response. Grant found the record sufficient to decide the work-permit dispute fairly and justly.
First, even assuming a duty of care existed, the evidence did not establish a breach of the required standard. Negligence law does not demand professional perfection. Grant treated the typo, which originated in Thomas's own application, as a minor error in the circumstances. The absence of an urgent correction request and IRCC's response a little over two months after receiving it supported the conclusion that any applicable standard had been met.
Second, misfeasance in public office required evidence of deliberate unlawful conduct by an official who knew both that it was unlawful and that it was likely to harm Thomas. There was no evidence supporting those elements. Describing conduct as reckless or wilfully blind did not supply the missing proof.
Third, causation failed independently. The judge found no evidentiary connection between the defendants' conduct and the range of alleged losses. The record did not show that those harms were reasonably foreseeable consequences of the typo or that the defendants' actions had contributed to them. Thomas's strongly held belief could not establish that link.
Provincial settlement dispute belonged outside Federal Court
The second branch of the action concerned compensation after Thomas was injured by an unidentified driver. He alleged a promised settlement payment had been delayed, causing financial hardship.
Records he submitted showed Ontario Superior Court proceedings involving the provincial Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Fund. The written settlement was for $95,000 including costs, rather than the $120,000 he described. It contained no promise of payment within two weeks and required assessment of his lawyer's bill before payment could proceed. That assessment and a consent judgment followed in July 2021.
Grant found that claims concerning the provincial process were outside the Federal Court's jurisdiction. As a statutory court, it needed a parliamentary grant of jurisdiction. The federal legislation Thomas invoked concerned the Crown in right of Canada, not the Crown in right of Ontario.
His belief that the permit problem and settlement delay combined to cause harm did not connect the provincial dispute to federal jurisdiction. The court therefore struck those claims without deciding that provincial officials were liable or that Thomas had a valid claim elsewhere.
Rights claims needed material facts
The remaining allegations invoked the Charter, the Canadian Human Rights Act and international instruments. Grant found that they lacked the material facts needed to support a cause of action.
The reasons distinguished the motion to strike from summary judgment. On the branch alleging no reasonable cause of action, pleaded facts generally had to be accepted as true, subject to exceptions, and evidence was inadmissible. Evidence could be considered on the separate frivolous-or-vexatious and abuse-of-process branches. Bare legal conclusions did not become sufficient pleadings merely because the court ordinarily assumed pleaded facts were true.
Thomas had not supplied facts connecting the typo to alleged violations of liberty, security or equality rights. The same deficiency affected his statutory discrimination claim. Grant also held that, even assuming an international instrument could independently support an action, the absence of material facts defeated that claim.
No amendment, with costs still to be addressed
After the hearing, Thomas informally sought to amend his claim and other materials to address more recent work-permit refusals. Grant denied the request. The rules required a motion and imposed conditions on amendments after a hearing, and Thomas had not explained how the changes could affect this proceeding.
The judge distinguished that damages action from a possible application for leave and judicial review of a later refusal, with an extension-of-time request if necessary. He did not decide whether such a separate challenge would succeed.
The entire action was dismissed. The defendants were presumptively entitled to costs, but no amount was fixed. The judgment allowed submissions of up to three pages within 10 days, after which the court would make a costs award if none were received.



