A British Columbia judge has refused to award costs to a trustee who argued that she had won an estate dispute because the plaintiffs ultimately obtained no remedy, finding that the parties had mixed success and that her own conduct independently justified leaving each side to pay its own costs.

In Reimer v. Reimer, 2026 BCSC 2208, Justice S. Ramsay also rejected Jacqueline Reimer's request for double costs, or ordinary costs after a settlement offer. The court found that a walk-away proposal made during trial was not an offer the plaintiffs ought reasonably to have accepted.

The November 16 decision leaves the existing own-costs disposition in place. It does not award damages or reopen the earlier findings about the estate of Jacqueline's father, Peter Reimer.

No remedy did not mean an unqualified victory

The litigation involved Jacqueline and her sisters, Jennifer and Amaris Reimer, over funds transferred to Jacqueline during their father's lifetime and the disposition of his estate.

In the January trial decision, Ramsay dismissed the plaintiffs' breach-of-fiduciary-duty claims but found that the disputed funds were held on resulting trust, rather than having been given to Jacqueline outright. The court also recognized a $197,600 equitable set-off for services she provided to her father and refused to vary his will.

In a September remedy decision, the plaintiffs obtained no remedy. Their proposed damages and estate-administration orders went beyond the pleadings, and their evidence and analysis did not establish the tracing relief sought against three properties. The judge nevertheless maintained that success at trial had been mixed.

The court had invited further costs submissions if the remedy ruling materially affected a party's position. Jacqueline took that opportunity, arguing that the absence of a remedy made her the successful party. Alternatively, she sought costs of the remedy-and-costs phase alone.

Ramsay rejected both approaches. At most, Jacqueline had succeeded on the discrete remedy issue; the costs issue itself remained mixed. Separating the remedy portion for its own costs assessment would be difficult, and the case did not justify the relatively unusual step of awarding costs by issue.

Independent reasons to refuse costs

Even if Jacqueline could properly be characterized as successful, Ramsay said the court would exercise its discretion against awarding her costs.

Jacqueline relied on an appeal decision identifying litigation misconduct, rejection of a settlement offer and success on discrete issues as reasons to depart from the usual costs rule. Ramsay explained that those examples were not exhaustive. The court retained broad discretion, exercised judicially in the circumstances of the case.

Two matters were important here. First, the earlier findings included at least one significant unauthorized personal purchase from the trust funds: a motorhome. The judge had also refused to declare that Jacqueline's lifetime expenditures were all within the conditions of the trust, given shortcomings in the evidence.

The current reasons refer to other transactions that raised questions, but the court did not resolve those questions. Nor did the costs ruling reverse the earlier dismissal of the fiduciary-duty claim. The relevant point was that the established personal use of trust funds counted against a discretionary costs award.

Second, Jacqueline's unsupported insistence that the transferred funds were a gift had shaped the pleadings and occupied significant trial time. Ramsay considered it unjust to award her costs of litigation that might have been avoided, or at least narrowed, had she acknowledged the true position.

Those considerations also defeated her alternative request for costs of the remedy issue alone.

The settlement offer did not justify double costs

Jacqueline made her formal offer on the evening of the second day of trial. It proposed ending the case on a walk-away basis, and the plaintiffs rejected it shortly afterwards.

The court assessed whether the offer should reasonably have been accepted using the circumstances when it was open, rather than simply comparing it with the eventual absence of a remedy.

The offer referred generally to that day's testimony without identifying which plaintiff's evidence mattered or explaining why. Both Jennifer and Amaris had testified. It gave them little assistance in evaluating their position, while Jacqueline had not yet testified on central issues concerning her credibility and dealings with the funds.

Ramsay also found no genuine compromise: the offer required dismissal without costs to any party. Other defendants were not copied and were not represented by Jacqueline's lawyer, and nothing showed that they had agreed to waive costs or sign a consent dismissal.

The proposed release extended beyond the claims in the proceeding. There was no evidence making the parties' relative financial circumstances a relevant factor. Finally, the same concerns about Jacqueline's trust-fund use and gift position weighed against exercising the settlement-costs discretion in her favour.

The judge therefore declined both double costs and ordinary costs for steps taken after the offer. Each party must bear their own costs of the proceeding.

Read the full decision on CanLII.