A Toronto excavation contractor was refused permission to take soil to a disposal site after its engineer left two elevated arsenic readings out of his report. Ontario’s engineering regulator found that Bing Hung Edward Wong and his firm, Edward Wong & Associates Inc., had fallen below professional standards in both their sampling and their account of the results.

In Association of Professional Engineers of Ontario (PEO) v Wong et al, 2025 ONAPE 3, the discipline panel ordered a one-week suspension of Wong’s licence and the firm’s certificate of authorization. It released its written reasons on April 10, 2025, following an April 7 hearing at which Wong admitted misconduct on behalf of himself and his firm.

Como Demolition and Excavation hired the firm in July 2022 to collect soil from a Toronto residential construction site, arrange chemical testing and report the results. Wong took four samples. Bureau Veritas Laboratories found elevated arsenic in two of them. At the contractor’s request, Wong returned and sampled soil that a backhoe had dug from a different location and depth. Those two new samples showed no excessive arsenic.

The panel explained why the second result could not settle the question raised by the first. The independent expert said a prudent engineer would have sampled at the same elevation to determine how far the higher arsenic concentrations extended. Wong took no photographs or field measurements on either visit. His report gave no locations for the two original elevated readings, no explanation for leaving them out and no test-pit or sample logs describing the soil.

At Wong’s request, the laboratory also issued a certificate covering only the two original samples without elevated readings. When the contractor submitted the firm’s report to United Soils Management, the receiving company’s environmental director already had the analyses for every sample. United Soils refused the soil, and the director complained to the regulator in February 2023.

The panel found negligence, failure to make responsible provision for compliance with applicable standards, and unprofessional conduct. The regulator withdrew a separate allegation about signing, dating or sealing an engineering document. The panel accepted that the arsenic exceedances were marginal, possibly natural in origin and posed no risk to the public in this case. It found no evidence that Wong or the firm had deliberately withheld the results for an improper purpose.

Both Wong and the firm received reprimands to be recorded indefinitely on the public register. The panel ordered publication of its findings and order with their names. Neither had previously been referred to the discipline committee. The panel credited their cooperation and acceptance of responsibility in agreeing to facts that spared the regulator a contested hearing.

The order gave Wong six months to pass the National Professional Practice Examination and twelve months to pass the Geotechnical & Hydrogeological Engineering examination, measured from pronouncement of the penalty. If he missed either deadline, he could practise only under the direct supervision of an engineer acceptable to the registrar. That engineer would have to take responsibility by signing and sealing each final drawing, report or other document Wong prepared or sealed. Passing each exam would lift the restriction attached to that exam.