
MEGlobal Canada ULC cannot obtain a downward transfer-pricing adjustment through a Tax Court appeal without the ministerial approval required by the Income Tax Act, the Federal Court of Appeal has ruled.
In MEGlobal Canada ULC v. Canada, 2026 FCA 24, the court dismissed an appeal from an order quashing the company’s tax appeal without leave to amend. The February 4 ruling applied the jurisdictional division established by the Supreme Court of Canada in Dow Chemical Canada ULC v. Canada, 2024 SCC 23.
Reassessments returned company to its original position
MEGlobal’s predecessor sold ethylene glycol products to a non-arm’s-length non-resident corporation. The agreed purchase price was the purchaser’s resale price less a 10 per cent discount. A later analysis led MEGlobal to conclude that the discount should instead have been 15 per cent.
Following an audit, the minister increased MEGlobal’s income through transfer-pricing adjustments for 2008, 2010 and 2011. MEGlobal objected to those increases and sought its own downward adjustment. Reassessments issued in 2016 reversed the increases, returning the company to its original filing position, but the minister refused the requested further reduction.
MEGlobal pursued both a Tax Court appeal and a Federal Court judicial review after the minister’s October 2018 refusal. The Tax Court quashed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction.
Pricing rule cannot be separated from approval requirement
Subsection 247(2) generally adjusts transactions between a taxpayer and a non-arm’s-length non-resident to reflect terms that arm’s-length parties would have agreed to. But subsection 247(10) prevents a downward adjustment unless the minister considers it appropriate in the circumstances.
The Supreme Court’s Dow Chemical decision established that reviewing the minister’s exercise of that discretion belongs to the Federal Court, not the Tax Court’s statutory assessment-appeal jurisdiction.
MEGlobal nevertheless argued that the Tax Court could first decide whether subsection 247(2), considered on its own, produced a downward adjustment. The appeal court rejected that approach. A finding about the arm’s-length price could not authorize a downward reassessment in the absence of the minister’s required opinion.
Proposed amendment could not supply jurisdiction
The Tax Court had noted a potential limitation-period problem if MEGlobal later obtained a favourable ministerial opinion after its appeal was quashed. But MEGlobal did not ask the appeal court to stay the Tax Court proceeding while its judicial review was decided. Instead, it sought permission to amend its pleading and have the taxation years referred back for reconsideration and reassessment on the basis of reduced taxable income.
The appeal court held that the Tax Court could not grant that relief. Its statutory powers to dispose of an assessment appeal did not include referring an issue back that might produce a reassessment only if the minister subsequently exercised discretion in the taxpayer’s favour.
The minister had also explained that the request would be refused even if MEGlobal’s proposed price were correct, citing the absence of taxation of the income in the other jurisdiction and the resulting concern about double non-taxation. The appeal court questioned why a separate pricing determination would first be needed in those circumstances.
The appeal was dismissed with costs. The ruling concerns the Tax Court’s jurisdiction and available remedy; it does not itself grant or decide MEGlobal’s separate judicial review of the minister’s refusal.



