An unsecured creditor can invoke the bona fide purchaser for value defence against a Crown claim for an employer’s unremitted payroll deductions after receiving proceeds from the employer’s asset sale, the Federal Court of Appeal has ruled.

Toronto-Dominion Bank (TD Canada Trust) v. Canada, 2026 FCA 25, decided February 9, overturned answers given on a preliminary question-of-law motion. It did not finally determine the bank’s liability in the underlying collection action.

Justice Wyman Webb, joined by Justices George Locke and Anne Mactavish, distinguished recovery from an innocent unsecured recipient from the Crown’s priority before sale proceeds are distributed. The court also preserved the distinction between unsecured creditors and secured creditors, who cannot rely on the same defence under the existing appellate authority.

Asset-sale proceeds paid overdrafts

The dispute arose after a restaurant operator failed to remit some deductions withheld from employees’ wages during 2013 to 2015. It sold its business assets for $100,000 in October 2015. TD received $37,595.07 in payments toward unsecured overdrafts over the following months, without making payment demands or exercising security.

The Canada Revenue Agency later sought $36,250.86 plus interest. TD had not known of the unremitted deductions before the agency notified it in January 2018. The agreed total included CPP and EI amounts, which have their own substantially similar statutory trust provisions. The precise Income Tax Act component was unclear, but the legal motion and appeal addressed that Act.

The Federal Court had answered that the deemed-trust provisions applied to unsecured creditors and that the bona fide purchaser defence was unavailable. The appeal court found the first question too broad for a simple answer. The relevant issue was recovery from an unsecured creditor after it received payment, not priority while the money remained with the debtor.

Statutory trust does not automatically exclude equity

The defence protects a person who acquires a legal interest for value, in good faith and without notice of a pre-existing equitable interest. Discharging an existing debt can supply value; the defence is not confined to someone buying a physical asset.

The Crown argued that an equitable defence could not answer a statutory trust claim unless Parliament expressly imported it. The court disagreed. Parliament used the language of trusts against an established legal background, and the provisions contain no express exclusion of the defence.

The requirement that sale proceeds be paid to the Receiver General establishes what must be paid and its priority. It does not expressly identify every recipient from whom diverted proceeds may later be recovered. Nor did the provision’s overriding language resolve that separate recovery question. Text therefore had to be read with statutory context and purpose.

Employees illustrated the consequences

Employees owed wages are also unsecured creditors. The court sought additional submissions on what would happen if an employer used asset-sale proceeds to pay them, only for the Crown later to reclaim those payments for the employer’s deduction arrears.

The wages would still have been taxable when received, while the employment-income deduction rules supplied no corresponding deduction for the later payment to the Crown. The Crown’s suggested adjustments did not answer the case law. That potentially harsh result supported making the defence available, and the statute did not distinguish employees from other unsecured creditors for this purpose.

The court acknowledged the apparent anomaly that an unsecured recipient may have a defence unavailable to a secured lender. Parliament had nevertheless given the Crown priority over security interests, and secured lenders were better positioned to manage the risk. The Crown also retained priority in undisbursed proceeds and its deemed trust over sufficient remaining debtor property. Recognizing the defence did not erase those protections.

The court set aside the preliminary order and substituted an answer confirming that an unsecured creditor can rely on the defence in the described circumstances. TD received the agreed costs of $1,400 for the appeal and $1,700 for the Federal Court proceeding. Availability of the defence, rather than a final adjudication of every element of TD’s underlying liability, was the ruling.