Amex Bank of Canada failed to overturn the denial of nearly $14 million in input tax credits for its credit-card rewards program, and the Supreme Court of Canada has since declined to hear its appeal.

In Amex Bank of Canada v. Canada, 2026 FCA 31, the Federal Court of Appeal upheld the Tax Court’s finding that the rewards expenses supported exempt financial services rather than taxable commercial activity. The appellate judgment was issued February 16. The Supreme Court docket records dismissal of Amex’s leave application with costs on October 29, 2026.

The leave refusal leaves the appellate result in place; it is not a separate Supreme Court decision on the merits of the tax issue.

Rewards tied to use of Amex cards

The dispute concerned $13,973,869.75 in disallowed credits across the 2002–2012 reporting periods. The claims related to GST/HST on rewards purchased from suppliers, program overhead and certain travel-certificate redemptions.

Membership was available only to Amex cardholders. Members earned points through eligible spending and redeemed them for rewards. Some cards included membership; others allowed enrolment for an additional fee. Amex also charged for certain points enhancements or purchases.

Amex argued that the Membership Rewards Program supplied taxable services separately from its credit-card financial services. The courts instead found the rewards and card services sufficiently interconnected to form a single composite supply to members.

Two distinct questions govern a composite supply

The appeal court distinguished the inquiry into whether services form one supply from the later inquiry into that supply’s character. First, a court examines their integration and interdependence. If there is one composite supply, it then identifies the predominant element, taking the recipient’s perspective into account.

The Tax Court properly found that the predominant element was extending credit. Points were an additional card benefit, and program membership had no independent commercial efficacy. The fact that card services could exist without rewards did not require treating the rewards arrangement as a separate supply.

Nor did the additional enrolment fee establish a separate taxable supply. The Tax Court could regard it as low compared with the program’s value. Amex’s appeal otherwise sought to reweigh factual findings without demonstrating the required palpable and overriding error.

The appeal court also rejected complaints about accounting evidence and references to merchant arrangements. Financial statements were not substituted for the legal test; they were evidence consistent with the program’s purpose of increasing card use and merchant-discount revenue. A misnamed agreement in the Tax Court reasons did not materially affect the analysis.

Coupon and promotional-supply arguments also failed

Amex separately claimed notional credits for travel certificates redeemed through affiliated agency franchisees. The coupon-redemption rule still required payments made in the course of commercial activity. Because the expenses supported exempt financial services, that condition was not met.

The court distinguished its 2024 President’s Choice Bank decision, where the bank participated in another business directed at driving retail traffic to Loblaws. The factual findings here were different: Amex’s program promoted spending on its cards and loyalty to Amex, not a taxable promotional service supplied to reward providers.

That distinction also defeated Amex’s reliance on the free-supply rule. The Tax Court had rejected the evidence that promoting reward providers’ businesses was one purpose of the rewards, and the appeal court found no reversible error in that conclusion.

The Federal Court of Appeal dismissed Amex’s appeal with costs. The decision turns on the structure and factual findings concerning this rewards program, rather than establishing that every loyalty arrangement necessarily receives identical GST/HST treatment.