Suncor Energy Inc. has won a Federal Court of Appeal ruling that allows depreciation timing to carry through a non-arm’s-length asset transfer even where the receiving partnership did not exist when the assets were originally purchased.

In Suncor Energy Inc. v. Canada, 2026 FCA 33, the court held that a statutory rule deeming the partnership to have acquired property earlier necessarily placed that acquisition in a notional taxation year. Without that implication, the related waiting period could never begin.

The February 19 judgment set aside the Tax Court’s dismissal and sent Suncor’s 2007 reassessment back to the minister on the basis that the disputed property was available for use during the partnership’s fiscal period ending January 31, 2007.

Assets acquired before partnership formation

Suncor bought $34,368,000 of Class 41 depreciable property in January 2005 for the Millennium Coker Unit project. The project was not completed in the taxation years at issue.

The Suncor Energy Oil Sands Limited Partnership was formed on February 1, 2005. Suncor held a 99.9 per cent interest, and its subsidiary held the balance. The partnership’s fiscal year ended January 31, unlike Suncor’s calendar tax year.

Suncor transferred the property to the partnership on January 1, 2006. The partnership added its cost to its undepreciated capital cost balance and claimed capital cost allowance for the fiscal period ending January 31, 2007. The resulting income allocation affected Suncor’s 2007 taxable income.

The minister disallowed the addition and related depreciation deduction, taking the position that the property was not yet available for use. The $34.368 million figure was the property’s cost base at issue, not the amount of tax relief awarded.

Making two statutory rules operate together

Capital cost allowance generally cannot be claimed before property becomes available for use. For assets in long-term projects not yet earning income, paragraph 13(27)(b) establishes a timing rule tied to a taxation year beginning more than 357 days after the end of the acquisition year.

Subsection 13(31), meanwhile, preserves continuity for certain transfers, including those between non-arm’s-length parties, by treating the recipient as having acquired the property when the transferor did.

The Tax Court accepted that the partnership was deemed to acquire the property in January 2005 but found it had no taxation year then because it did not yet exist. The appeal court held that this interpretation prevented the provisions from achieving their purpose.

A deemed acquisition in a taxation year was a necessary implication of the statutory scheme. For this limited timing calculation, the recipient must be treated as acquiring the asset in the taxation year it would have had if it existed then, using its subsequently adopted fiscal period.

Reorganization context supported continuity

The court found no indication that Parliament intended assets acquired in January 2005 to be stranded outside the timing rule while assets purchased earlier or later could qualify through other applications of the same scheme.

The provision also expressly applied to butterfly reorganizations, which commonly transfer assets to newly formed corporations. Reading it to require an actual pre-existing tax year would undermine that application. The court rejected the Crown’s contention that separate winding-up continuity rules resolved the problem in the example before it.

The result does not generally deem a partnership to have existed before formation. The notional year serves the limited statutory purpose of determining when the property becomes available for use.

Suncor received costs in the Tax Court and appeal costs calculated at the midpoint of Column III of Tariff B, as the parties had agreed. The judgment did not set a dollar amount for those costs.