
The Federal Court of Appeal has applied the general anti-avoidance rule to a company that continued into the British Virgin Islands before realizing an investment gain, while its management and control remained in Ontario.
In Canada v. DAC Investment Holdings Inc., 2026 FCA 35, the court reversed the Tax Court’s decision and dismissed DAC’s tax appeal, awarding costs at both levels. The judgment was delivered February 20, with amended reasons issued March 11. DAC has since applied for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada; its public docket showed no leave decision when checked November 17.
A corporate move before a share sale
DAC acquired shares from another Canadian-controlled private corporation through a tax-deferred rollover in April 2015. The shares were DAC’s only assets. Later that month it continued into the British Virgin Islands, causing it to cease qualifying as a Canadian-controlled private corporation, or CCPC, for income-tax purposes.
Its central management and control nevertheless remained in Ontario. In May 2015 it sold the shares to an arm’s-length purchaser, realizing a capital gain of approximately $2.36 million.
DAC filed as a Canadian-resident private corporation that was not a CCPC. The minister applied the general anti-avoidance rule, known as GAAR, and reassessed $239,219 in additional Part I tax, plus interest. The additional tax reflected refundable tax on investment income and denial of the general corporate rate reduction.
The parties agreed that DAC received a tax benefit and that both the rollover and continuance were avoidance transactions. The disputed question was whether those transactions abused the legislation.
Literal compliance was not the end of the analysis
The Tax Court had accepted that Parliament permitted corporations to move between CCPC and non-CCPC regimes, each with advantages and disadvantages. The appeal court held that this reasoning expressed Parliament’s intention too broadly. Even a transaction complying with the statutory text can attract GAAR when it defeats the provisions’ underlying rationale.
The relevant investment-income rules were intended to limit opportunities for individuals to defer tax by earning investment income through a CCPC. The rule treating a continued corporation as incorporated in its new jurisdiction formed part of a scheme intended to make taxation fairer for corporations moving into or leaving Canada.
DAC’s continuance did not involve developing British Virgin Islands business interests or ties. Apart from the tax benefits, it was virtually inconsequential to the company, the court found. Using that change to circumvent the anti-deferral rules frustrated both sets of provisions.
The court also rejected reliance on merely theoretical disadvantages of losing CCPC status. Such disadvantages mattered only if they were material to DAC, and the court was not persuaded they were.
Ruling left broader question open
The Crown had argued that the anti-deferral provisions’ purpose extended to all private corporations, not just CCPCs. The court did not decide that broader issue. It found abuse even assuming the provisions’ underlying purpose was limited to CCPCs.
DAC also argued that, if treated under GAAR as subject to CCPC investment-income rules, it should receive a CCPC’s shorter normal reassessment period. That would have made the reassessment late. The court rejected the argument because GAAR’s remedial power permitted adjustments to deny the tax benefit, not the proposed change to the reassessment period.
The judges drew no inference about earlier legislative intent from amendments effective in 2022. The decision addresses the transactions and statutory regime before the court, not every corporate continuance abroad.
The Supreme Court docket records DAC’s leave application filed April 21, 2026. Seeking leave is not the same as receiving permission to appeal, and the appellate ruling should not be described as having received Supreme Court endorsement.



