
Incorrect advice from the Canada Revenue Agency could not give a taxpayer a right to appeal a reassessment that Parliament had placed outside the objection process, the Federal Court of Appeal ruled.
In Siam v. Canada, 2026 FCA 91, delivered from the bench on May 11, the court upheld the quashing of Mohamed Siam’s tax appeal. It also rejected his challenge to the Tax Court’s finding about an earlier assessment that determined when the normal assessment period ended.
Why the earlier assessment mattered
Siam sought to appeal an August 18, 2023 reassessment concerning his 2016 tax year. The Tax Court found that his notice of objection was invalid because the reassessment had been issued under subsection 152(4.2) of the Income Tax Act after the normal assessment period expired.
That provision permits the minister to reassess in response to a taxpayer’s application for a refund or tax reduction made within 10 years after the relevant tax year. Subsection 165(1.2), however, prohibits objections to those reassessments.
The Tax Court concluded that the normal period ended on April 19, 2021, three years after the original assessment dated April 19, 2018. Siam argued that he received the earlier assessment only later, so the normal period had not begun in 2018.
The appeal court emphasized the distinction between sending and receiving a notice: the statutory period begins when the original assessment is sent. Siam bore the burden of establishing on a balance of probabilities that it had not been sent.
Credibility could be assessed at the first step
The court applied the existing Mpamugo framework. A taxpayer can assert that a notice was not received and therefore was believed not to have been mailed, or that it was sent to the wrong address through no fault of the taxpayer. The Tax Court may assess the credibility of that assertion after hearing all the evidence.
Here, the Tax Court considered both routes and did not find Siam’s evidence credible. The appeal court saw no indication that it had failed to consider evidence before reaching that conclusion. Because Siam had not passed the first step, the Tax Court did not have to proceed through the remaining steps of the framework.
Siam also relied on the Crown’s affidavit describing the assessment as issued rather than confirming it was mailed. The appeal court was not persuaded that the affidavit’s wording and the 2023 reassessment established an error in the Tax Court’s approach.
Intervention in the weighing of evidence required an obvious error affecting the outcome. None was shown. The court also found it understandable that the Tax Court considered Siam likely aware of the assessment by 2019 at the latest, supporting expiry of the normal period before the 2023 reassessment.
CRA advice did not override the statute
Siam argued that both the CRA officer and the reassessment itself had told him he could object, creating a legitimate expectation of a Tax Court appeal. The court acknowledged the incorrect information and said the CRA should review its practices.
But legitimate expectations can affect procedural rights, not create a substantive appeal right prohibited by legislation. The court dismissed the appeal with costs, without specifying an amount. It did not decide the merits of Siam’s underlying tax position.



