Selling a business division and losing its knowledgeable employees did not end a taxpayer’s obligation to make reasonable inquiries during discovery, the Tax Court of Canada has ruled in a dispute over GST/HST on securities-related services.

In RF Securities Clearing LP v. The King, 2026 TCC 120, issued June 24, Justice Guy R. Smith ordered further answers and document production on several issues. But the court also rejected repetitive questions and excused further responses about clients whose assessments the taxpayer no longer contested.

The order resolved discovery disputes, not whether the services were taxable. The Crown was awarded costs under the applicable tariff.

What services were actually supplied?

RF Securities, formerly GMP Securities LP, disputed GST/HST reassessments covering monthly reporting periods from 2014 through 2016. It maintained that success fees paid by clients related to arranging securities transactions and were consideration for exempt financial services.

The minister took a different view: the firm had provided financial and strategic advice, without direct involvement in issuing, selling or purchasing securities. The nature of the actual services therefore lay at the centre of the appeal.

The relevant business division had been sold in December 2019. RF Securities said the employees involved no longer worked for it, that it had produced hundreds of documents and that further demands were disproportionate. It also argued that some questions sought counsel’s work product, legal opinions or the evidence it would use at trial.

The Crown wanted client-specific facts explaining what the firm did, which transactions it arranged and which documents it created. General references to the entire production did not answer those questions, it argued.

Partial disclosure was not a discovery ceiling

The parties had agreed to the document-listing procedure under Rule 81. Smith found that this did not confine all subsequent discovery to documents already listed.

Rule 95 required reasonable inquiries of relevant current and former officers, employees and agents, including where necessary to become better informed. That obligation was particularly important where the business had been sold and employees had departed. The reasons did not impose a free-standing duty to obtain documents from every third-party adviser.

The court also distinguished asking for the facts underlying a legal position from improperly asking what evidence a party would use to prove it. A fact does not become undiscoverable merely because it could later be evidence at trial.

Several disputed questions sought the factual basis for RF Securities’ account of its services, not privileged legal advice. The firm was ordered to make further inquiries and provide more specific answers.

Limits mattered as well

The ruling did not accept every Crown demand. RF Securities had confirmed that it would no longer contest assessments relating to seven clients. The court treated this as an ordinary concession, without requiring an amended notice of appeal, and found further questions about those clients unnecessary.

Two groups of questions repeated requests already substantially answered or otherwise addressed through questions about the same activities. Reframing them under success fees or summary lead sheets did not justify additional responses.

For the remaining clients, the firm had to identify who prepared engagement letters on a best-efforts basis, or explain that it could not confirm authorship. It also had to provide the available documents or a representative sample explaining how many were omitted and how the selection was made.

Proper follow-up questions arising from the ordered answers also had to be answered. Relevance and proportionality remained the governing considerations, not an unrestricted demand for every possible record.

The court emphasized that discovery enables each side to understand the other’s factual case before trial. Whether RF Securities ultimately proved entitlement to the financial-services exemption remained a separate question for the trial judge.