British Columbia’s Court of Appeal has ordered a new assessment of competing damages awards in a dispute over distribution of the independent horror film Puppet Killer, finding that an arbitrator had not explained one $50,000 award and had contradicted his own findings in granting the other.

In Puppet Killer Productions Inc. v. Industryworks Studios Inc., 2026 BCCA 311, the unanimous court sent both amounts, along with the costs of the initial arbitration, back to the arbitrator. It capped the distributor’s recoverable expenses at $16,000 but declined the producer’s request to substitute a $100,000 award for its own additional losses.

The July 24 judgment left undisputed findings of contractual breach, the $150,000 minimum distribution guarantee and prejudgment interest outside the issues being reconsidered. It did not determine the final additional compensation payable to the producer.

A distribution deal followed by arbitration

Puppet Killer Productions made the film in 2019 on a $150,000 budget. Its April 2020 agreement with Industryworks Studios granted exclusive distribution rights for 25 years. The producer was to receive 70 per cent of gross revenue and, in any event, a minimum guarantee of $150,000.

Industryworks released the film theatrically in September 2021 and arranged international sub-distribution. That December, it purported to terminate the agreement over alleged technical delivery deficiencies and refused to pay the guarantee. The producer accepted the repudiation and demanded the film’s return, but the distributor continued marketing and distributing it.

The dispute proceeded through an expedited arbitration based on written evidence, without cross-examination. The process limited potential damages awards to $250,000, excluding interest and costs.

The arbitrator found several breaches by Industryworks, including failure to notify the producer of defects so they could be corrected, non-payment of the guarantee, continued distribution after termination and failure to provide accounting statements. He ordered the film’s immediate return and awarded the producer the guarantee, $50,000 in additional damages and $21,324.62 in prejudgment interest.

Against that $221,324.62 total, he set off $50,000 for the distributor’s expenses, leaving a net award of $171,324.62. He directed each side to bear its own costs because neither had been fully successful. The appeal concerned the additional damages, the expense award and costs, rather than reopening the breach findings.

Missing accounts did not require an adverse inference

The producer argued that the distributor’s failure to provide accounting records prevented it from establishing the film’s earnings and should have led to an adverse inference when assessing damages.

Justice Mayer, writing for the court, rejected that ground. The producer had not asked the arbitrator to draw the inference, and the distributor had not been given an opportunity to respond to such a request. The arbitrator had considered the missing accounts as a contractual breach, not as a proposed basis for inferring a particular loss.

An adverse inference was not mandatory. Raising that new argument on appeal was especially problematic in an appeal from an arbitral award. The court also treated the decision whether to draw such an inference as a factual matter entitled to deference and found no palpable and overriding error.

Why the producer’s damages needed another hearing

The producer succeeded on a different ground: neither the arbitrator’s reasons nor the record explained why its additional loss was worth $50,000.

Its evidence included competing projections of potential distribution earnings, and it had sought $100,000 beyond the minimum guarantee to remain within the expedited process’s damages ceiling. Industryworks, by contrast, reported no earnings from North American screenings and approximately $16,875 in gross international sub-distribution earnings.

The arbitrator found that withholding the film deprived the producer of an opportunity to market it itself or secure another distributor. But he did not quantify that opportunity or accept or reject the conflicting earnings evidence.

The court explained that reasons must be considered generously, with the record, rather than parsed for imperfections. Intervention was warranted here because the unexplained figure prevented meaningful appellate review.

That did not establish that the producer’s preferred $100,000 figure was correct. Industryworks challenged the reliability of the projected earnings. Resolving those factual disputes belonged in a new arbitration on the additional damages, not in a replacement calculation by the appeal court.

The distributor’s expenses were capped

The parties also disputed the legal basis for the $50,000 set-off. The producer argued that, absent a finding that it breached its delivery obligations, only unjust enrichment could support the award—and that theory had not been pleaded. Industryworks defended the award as an equitable set-off.

The court instead read the award as compensation for expenses recoverable under the distribution contract. The arbitrator had not analyzed unjust enrichment or found that the distributor supplied assistance beyond the agreement. His discussion focused on contractual expenses, including a finding that employee labour was not an eligible third-party expense.

The problem was that his ultimate $50,000 figure conflicted with his finding that expenses could be recovered only from gross receipts, which he had fixed at $16,000 for that purpose. It also could not be reconciled with his requirement that the producer approve expenses for materials: there was no evidence of that approval.

Forgetting or ignoring evidence in a way that affected the result constituted an error of law. The court returned the expense assessment to the arbitrator, subject to a $16,000 ceiling because the finding imposing that limit had not been appealed. The ceiling was not an award of the full amount.

Costs also returned to the arbitrator

Both parties had requested enhanced costs, and the producer was refused permission to make further costs submissions after the award. It challenged both that refusal and the arbitrator’s reliance on neither party being fully successful.

The appeal court confirmed that ordinary costs generally turn on substantial success, rather than complete success, and that failing to seek costs submissions may amount to an error in principle. It nevertheless left the initial arbitration’s costs for the arbitrator to decide alongside the reassessed damages, rather than awarding them itself.

Source: Puppet Killer Productions Inc. v. Industryworks Studios Inc., 2026 BCCA 311.