STC Steel Technologies Canada has lost a tax appeal over which exchange rate applied to losses inherited from a subsidiary that reported in Canadian dollars, while the parent reported in U.S. dollars.

In STC Steel Technologies Canada, Ltd. v. The King, 2026 TCC 149, decided August 12, 2026, Tax Court Justice Jenna Clark upheld a US$2,073,494 non-capital loss deduction for the company’s taxation year ending December 31, 2021.

The company’s corrected position would have produced US$2,651,791 in available losses. Those figures describe deductible losses, not the amount of tax payable or a cash award.

Same losses, different reporting currencies

The case proceeded entirely on agreed facts. STC had elected to report its Canadian tax results in U.S. dollars for its taxation year ending March 31, 2011. Its subsidiary, Kasle Steel of Canada Ltd., had not made that election and reported in Canadian dollars.

Kasle Steel’s winding-up began and ended on December 2, 2020. It held C$2,693,199 in non-capital losses arising in taxation years ending in 2009, 2010 and 2011.

Both sides agreed that the losses ultimately became STC’s under the Income Tax Act’s winding-up rules and that they had to be converted into U.S. dollars. Their dispute was about when conversion occurred and whose tax history determined the exchange rate.

STC argued that the losses first became its own, deemed to arise in the parent’s years corresponding to the subsidiary’s loss years. Conversion would then follow the parent’s functional-currency history. The Crown maintained that the losses had to be converted while still held by Kasle Steel, using the rate on December 31, 2019, the last day of the subsidiary’s last Canadian-currency year.

A same-day wind-up did not escape the rule

Subsection 261(16) addresses a qualifying wind-up where parent and subsidiary have different tax-reporting currencies. It brings a Canadian-dollar-reporting subsidiary into the parent’s functional-currency regime for the year that includes the start of the wind-up.

STC argued that the rule did not apply because Kasle Steel’s final taxation year ended on the same day the wind-up started, rather than in a later year. The judge rejected that reading.

The statute refers to a commencement time, not merely a commencement day. Completion of the wind-up and the subsidiary’s resulting year-end necessarily followed its commencement, even though both occurred on December 2. The wording also expressly included the taxation year containing that commencement time.

Nil income did not leave the losses outside the regime

STC also argued that the provision concerned the subsidiary’s Canadian tax results, whereas Kasle Steel had no income against which the losses were deducted in its final year.

The court accepted that the unused losses were not themselves part of the subsidiary’s Canadian tax results for that year. But it rejected the conclusion STC drew from that point: a nil result was still a tax result that had to be determined under the applicable rules.

Once subsection 261(16) brought Kasle Steel into the functional-currency system, subsection 261(5) applied and made the final year a functional-currency year. That, in turn, triggered subsection 261(7), requiring relevant amounts from earlier Canadian-currency years to be converted.

The loss-conversion provision covers amounts that may be deducted. The judge held that this includes an available loss pool even if no deduction is actually claimed in that year. The court considered both the English and French wording and found them consistent on that point.

Conversion and transfer rules worked together

The judge also examined the statutory purpose and explanatory notes. The regime aligns the subsidiary’s reporting currency with the parent’s and converts tax attributes before they pass through the wind-up.

That did not displace the separate rule transferring the losses to STC. Instead, the provisions operated in sequence: Kasle Steel’s losses were converted into U.S. dollars in its hands, then became the parent’s losses on the wind-up.

The result was conversion at the December 31, 2019 spot rate of 1.29887, supporting the reassessed US$2,073,494 deduction. The court dismissed the appeal.

The judgment set a timetable for the parties to agree on costs or make submissions, with tariff costs to the Crown if neither occurred. It did not fix a dollar amount in these reasons. The ruling turns on the interaction of the wind-up and functional-currency rules where the two corporations report in different currencies, not on a general refusal to transfer subsidiary losses.