The Tax Court of Canada has declined to put seven corporate residency appeals and a shareholder’s personal tax appeal into a single trial on common evidence, warning that a procedural consolidation motion should not decide contested questions reserved for trial.

Instead, in Tiencon Electronics Export Company Limited v. The King, 2026 TCC 148, issued August 12, Justice Laurie A. Goldbach directed that the corporate appeals and Adrian Robinson’s individual appeal be heard consecutively by the same judge. That judge would decide which proceeded first.

No costs were awarded because success on the motion was divided. The ruling did not determine anyone’s tax residency or the validity of the underlying assessments.

Related appeals raised contested residency questions

The seven corporate appeals had already been consolidated with each other. Robinson’s individual appeal had been moving along a parallel procedural track after an earlier request to hold it in abeyance was dismissed.

The minister asserted that Robinson, who directly or indirectly held half the shares in each corporate appellant, lived in Canada and managed and controlled the companies from Canada with another person. Robinson disputed his personal tax residency, including the possible effect of the Canada-U.K. tax treaty if he was a dual resident.

The parties disagreed about how the corporate and personal residency tests interacted. The Crown argued that shareholder residency was a fundamental corporate-residency consideration. The appellants maintained that central management and control was a factual question not requiring evidence of Robinson’s personal residency.

A discovery dispute sharpened the issue. Robinson had testified as the appellants’ nominee, but counsel objected when he was asked in the corporate appeals to adopt his answers from the individual appeal. The Crown said a common-evidence consolidation would remove the need for a motion over that refusal.

Efficiency could not settle the merits indirectly

Goldbach found that ordering a common-evidence trial risked appearing to endorse the Crown’s position about the relevance of personal-residency evidence to the corporate cases. Conversely, ordering the corporate cases to proceed first, as the appellants proposed, risked endorsing their contrary position.

Neither inference was appropriate on this motion. The relevance and weight of evidence, the legal tests and their possible overlap belonged to the trial judge.

The court rejected an overly narrow reading of the consolidation rule: a common question need not be determinative of all appeals. But the rule still should not be used to obtain a substantive advantage or settle central evidentiary disputes prematurely.

Refusing a common-evidence trial also did not transfer the burden of proof to the minister. Each appellant retained the burden of disproving the minister’s residency assumptions. Other procedural tools remained available to address disputed admissions.

One judge, consecutive hearings

Consecutive hearings before the same judge offered a practical middle course. They reduced the risk of inconsistent judgments while leaving the parties able to agree on shared facts or evidence and the judge able to determine objections.

The parties were directed to provide hearing estimates for either possible order of proceeding. The existing timetable remained operative. These were directions for managing the appeals, not findings that the hearings had occurred or that any residency issue had been resolved.