Manitoba’s Appeal Commission has dismissed a paramedic’s challenge to the method used to calculate workers’ compensation benefits, distinguishing a casual employee who chooses available shifts from a casual emergency worker under the province’s legislation.

In Decision 54/26, signed August 19, 2026, the panel upheld the Workers Compensation Board’s use of the worker’s earnings over the 12 months before the accident. It found that approach fairly reflected earnings that fluctuated with the shifts the worker chose to accept.

The dispute was about the earnings calculation, not whether the workplace injury claim was acceptable. The claim had been accepted and wage-loss benefits paid. The reasons also record that an overpayment arising from an earlier calculation error was written off, not ordered repaid.

Emergency duties did not settle the worker’s statutory status

The worker had moved from full-time to casual employment in 2017 and was a casual primary care paramedic at the time of the accident. The worker argued that the statutory definition of a casual emergency worker applied and that using past earnings did not accurately capture normal or potential income.

The argument relied on section 1(4)(d) of The Workers Compensation Act. That provision addresses a member of a municipal or community ambulance service who is available on a casual basis to respond as needed to emergency ambulance calls, with membership approved by the specified ambulance-service or municipal authority. It can apply with or without remuneration.

The worker pointed to similarities between the collective agreement’s casual-employee definition and the statutory wording, along with text messages asking for shifts to be filled urgently. The worker said they responded to the employer’s requests rather than giving availability in advance, and that their work involved answering emergency ambulance calls.

The employer argued that the worker could choose whether to accept shifts and that working casually in an emergency setting was not enough to establish the statutory status. It maintained that the earnings calculation fairly reflected the worker’s wage history.

The panel accepted that the paramedic responded to emergency calls while working. But it found the worker was not in an on-call position and was not required to remain available or accept the employer’s requests. If unavailable, the worker could simply decline to take a shift.

That distinction also answered the text-message argument. The panel accepted that the employer sometimes urgently needed vacant shifts covered. It did not equate that staffing urgency with being available to respond to an emergency ambulance call in the sense contemplated by the legislation.

The panel rejected an interpretation that would automatically include every casual paramedic who answers emergency calls as part of regular duties. It also contrasted this worker’s circumstances with mobilization for a particular emergency or disaster. That was part of its assessment of the evidence, not a declaration that every qualifying ambulance worker must respond to a major disaster or that paramedics can never qualify.

Irregular earnings supported the yearly average

Having rejected the claimed statutory status, the panel separately considered whether the WCB had used the correct earnings formula.

Section 45 permits the WCB to calculate average earnings from employment income and employment insurance benefits over a period it considers fair and just. The Average Earnings Policy, 44.80.10.10, directs it to select the formula that best reflects the worker’s employment and earnings pattern before the accident.

The reasons describe three approaches. Regular earnings are based on what the worker would normally receive in the relevant employment. Average yearly earnings address fluctuating income and generally use a consecutive 12-month period, with the policy allowing other historical periods where they provide a more accurate picture. Probable yearly earning capacity forecasts expected earnings where the other approaches would not accurately reflect what the worker likely would have earned, subject to sufficient certainty about that expectation.

For this worker, the panel found that the regular-earnings approach would not accurately represent the pre-accident pattern. The worker had voluntarily switched to casual employment and earnings varied with accepted shifts. Using the previous 12 months under the Average Yearly Earnings Formula was consistent with both the Act and the policy, it concluded.

Earlier overpayment was written off

The initial calculation had inadvertently included retroactive wage payments. After the employer identified those amounts, the WCB recalculated average earnings and advised that an overpayment had resulted. The reasons state that the overpayment was written off.

The panel found no evidence that the revised calculation, excluding those payments, conflicted with the Act or policy. It dismissed the appeal without directing repayment or setting a new dollar award. The decision does not establish that every casual worker must always be assessed using the immediately preceding 12 months; its conclusion rests on this worker’s employment and earnings pattern.