
The Federal Court of Appeal has vacated a $6.49-million assessment against Harvard Properties Inc., finding that the company gave full-value consideration in a shopping-mall transaction and was not liable for another company’s alleged tax debt.
In Harvard Properties Inc. v. Canada, 2026 FCA 142, dated August 27, 2026 and corrected on August 28, the Court also found that the Tax Court had decided the case unfairly by questioning a property value that neither party disputed.
The unanimous decision allowed Harvard’s appeal with costs in both courts and dismissed the Minister’s cross-appeal with costs. Rather than ordering a new trial, the Court set aside the Tax Court judgment and vacated Harvard’s January 11, 2017 assessment.
A mall sale structured through shares
Harvard owned a half interest in a shopping mall, with four other co-owners holding the balance. In 2005, Abacus Capital Corporation offered $89.8 million for the property but proposed acquiring shares in newly created companies rather than buying the mall directly.
Harvard transferred its interest, valued at $44.9 million, to a new subsidiary in exchange for the subsidiary assuming related debt and issuing voting and preferred shares. Harvard used a tax election that deferred recognition of the full proceeds on that transfer.
It then sold the shares to NH Properties, an Abacus subsidiary. The new company sold Harvard’s former interest in the mall to third-party purchaser Bentall, while the other co-owners carried out corresponding transactions. Bentall acquired the entire mall for $89.8 million.
Two payments to Harvard ultimately remained in dispute: approximately $6.92 million to discharge a promissory note issued for voting shares, and $7.98 million as part payment for preferred shares. The Minister conceded that a separate $700,000 payment was not subject to the transfer-liability provision.
Harvard paid approximately $1.8 million in tax on its share sales. The Court found that it ended up with roughly $14.8 million after tax, essentially the same amount it would have retained from selling its mall interest directly.
Why Harvard faced another company’s tax bill
In 2015, the Minister reassessed the new company’s successor, disallowing losses used to offset the gain on the mall sale. Two years later, Harvard was assessed under section 160 of the Income Tax Act for a liability then totalling $6,492,962, including $3,287,785 in federal tax plus interest and penalties.
Section 160 can make a recipient jointly liable for a transferor’s tax debt where property moves between parties not dealing at arm’s length. Liability is limited by the difference between the value received and the value given in exchange.
The proceedings were split so that the underlying tax liability would be determined separately. Harvard’s case concerned the other requirements for transfer liability and the Minister’s alternative reliance on the general anti-avoidance rule, or GAAR. The appeal did not resolve whether the new company actually owed the disputed tax debt.
The Tax Court upheld Harvard’s assessment. It concluded that Harvard and the Abacus companies were not dealing at arm’s length and that Harvard had given no consideration for the payments. It also held that GAAR supported the assessment.
An undisputed value became a decisive issue
The appeal court found that the Tax Court’s reasoning depended on Harvard receiving a premium above the mall’s fair market value, funded by unpaid taxes. But the Minister accepted the $89.8-million value, and the Tax Court had told Harvard that it did not need to address that issue.
The Tax Court nevertheless rejected that value and faulted Harvard for not producing valuation evidence. The Federal Court of Appeal held that deciding the case on a basis outside the parties’ pleadings, evidence and positions was an error of law and procedurally unfair.
A court could have raised concerns about the value and given Harvard an opportunity to respond. That did not happen. A new trial was unnecessary because the record led to one conclusion: the contemporaneous price paid by the third-party buyer established the $89.8-million value, which the Minister did not challenge.
Full consideration and an arm’s-length transaction
The Court also rejected the finding that Harvard received a premium from unpaid taxes. Unlike the earlier Microbjo case, there was no evidence of an agreement to share funds that otherwise would have paid the new company’s tax liability. Harvard’s unchanged after-tax position and its own $1.8-million tax payment reinforced that distinction.
Without the unsupported premium finding, the basis for treating the parties as non-arm’s-length fell away. That conclusion was enough to defeat section 160, but the Court separately found that Harvard had provided fair market value consideration.
That value had to be assessed when each transfer occurred, not by looking ahead to the new company later having no assets or business. Discharging the genuine $6.92-million debt involved relinquishing a promissory note of corresponding value. Payment-protection arrangements, including escrow and trust accounts, did not make the preferred shares worthless in Harvard’s hands.
The anti-avoidance argument also failed
The Court considered GAAR separately, assuming for its analysis the tax benefit identified by the Tax Court: avoiding liability for the new company’s tax debt.
The Tax Court had treated the creation and sale of voting shares, which removed Harvard’s control of the new company, as avoidance transactions. The appeal court found that analysis flawed. Losing legal control did not itself determine whether the parties dealt at arm’s length as a matter of fact, and the evidence established that they did.
In any event, there was no misuse or abuse of section 160. Its protective purpose addresses below-value transfers between non-arm’s-length parties. Harvard dealt at arm’s length and supplied full consideration for the disputed payments.
The Minister’s cross-appeal about the identity of the tax debtor therefore no longer needed to be decided. The ruling does not provide a general exemption for share-sale structures: it turns on the accepted property value, the evidence of the parties’ relationship and the consideration given at the relevant times.



