
A startup worker who had asked to become an independent contractor was nevertheless an employee for Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance purposes during the period before the Tax Court of Canada.
In Lees v. M.N.R., Justice Lara Friedlander allowed Chelsea Lees’s appeal from the Minister’s classification decision. The September 8, 2026 judgment directed reconsideration and reassessment on the basis that her work was pensionable and insurable employment from January 1, 2023 to October 15, 2024. No costs were awarded.
The label did not settle the substance
Lees worked in media, communications and product design for SXNM Successionmatching Ltd., which matched buyers and sellers of businesses. After initially being hired as an employee, she requested contractor status to preserve freedom to pursue other work.
Later letters used contractor language. She invoiced, charged GST and reported business income, while the payer did not make employment-related deductions. The court accepted that these features supported an expressed intention to use a contractor relationship.
But the letters said little about core matters such as scheduling, supervision, tools and delegation. The judge found limited evidence that the parties shared an intention to create an independent business relationship in substance. The actual work also increasingly diverged from the tasks described in the letters.
Control and economic reality pointed to employment
The payer selected tasks according to its changing needs, met with Lees frequently to review progress, and controlled when she worked. She needed approval for vacation and some outside activities. Those findings favoured employment.
Although Lees supplied her laptop and telephone, the payer supplied much of the software central to her evolving role. The court treated ownership of tools as neutral, not decisive.
Fixed hours and fixed compensation left no material opportunity for entrepreneurial profit or risk of loss. Possible bonuses and revenue participation were contingent and did not materialize. Lees could not delegate or subcontract her duties, and restrictions prevented her from working directly for the payer’s clients.
The judge also considered the sustained, broad managerial role and whether Lees was conducting her own business through that work. On the evidence, the work belonged to the payer’s business.
A statutory classification decision
The payer did not participate as an intervenor, and Lees was the sole witness; the court found her credible and reliable. Applying the governing multifactor test, the judge held that the relationship’s legal substance outweighed its stated label.
The decision determines CPP and EI status for the specified period. It does not award wrongful-dismissal damages or decide employment-standards entitlements.
Read the official reasons and order. This is an unofficial report of the decision.



