
The Manitoba Court of Appeal upheld Malcolm McLeod’s convictions for aggravated assault and break-and-enter involving firearm robbery, while cautioning police about influencing witnesses’ accounts.
In R v McLeod, 2026 MBCA 80, decided September 25, 2026, the court noted an officer named the accused to some witnesses and mentioned a gun and knife before one witness gave his recollection.
The trial judge addressed that risk, discarded one witness’s identification and separately assessed the remaining testimony. No reviewable error was established.
The court also rejected a bias argument arising from the judge’s preliminary inquiry into co-accused charges. That inquiry was procedural and justified.
Nor did it find error in declining a special caution about a key identification witness’s reliability, known as a Vetrovec warning. The judge found no evidence he participated in the offences, noted his lack of criminal record and community activity, and treated inconsistencies as minor.



