An Alberta corporation has lost its attempt to reclassify employment income paid to two shareholder-workers as dividends after the fact, leaving its Canada Pension Plan contribution assessments intact.

In 563768 Alberta Inc. v. M.N.R., 2026 TCC 181, decided October 19, 2026, Tax Court Justice Bruce Russell dismissed the company’s appeal without costs. The judgment upheld assessments for 2020, 2021 and January 1 to July 31, 2022.

Amended slips were not enough

The corporation had issued T4 slips reporting employment earnings and CPP contributions for its two shareholder-workers. The minister assessed it for contributions it had failed to remit, using the earlier T4 information to estimate the partial 2022 period when no current contributions had been remitted.

The company objected. The assessment history included a reduction of the partial-year 2022 assessment and a revised 2020 assessment intended to preserve appeal rights after a credit was transferred between years. Written decisions dated December 7, 2023 confirmed the assessments that reached the court.

The company’s notice of appeal said the Canada Revenue Agency had agreed to adjust a T4 slip to reclassify the income as dividends but had not processed the amendment. The Crown disputed that an agreement had been made. The court did not find that CRA had agreed to the change.

Employment status was conceded

At the hearing, the corporation’s representative conceded that the two workers were employees. An earlier suggestion that they were self-employed was not pursued, and no evidence displaced the minister’s assumptions about their employee status.

That left the question of whether payments already reported as employment income could be recharacterized as dividends received in the workers’ capacity as shareholders. The proposed dividend treatment would not trigger the CPP obligations at issue.

Tax consequences follow what was actually done

The judge applied Supreme Court of Canada authority distinguishing a taxpayer’s freedom to structure transactions from an attempt to change their tax consequences retrospectively.

The company could originally have chosen to distribute income through wages or dividends. But the court held that taxpayers are taxed on the arrangements they actually made and carried out, not on arrangements they later wished they had chosen. On that basis, the company could not change the character of these payments by adjusting already issued T4 slips after the fact.

The appeal was dismissed and the assessments remained valid. The Crown did not seek costs, and the court found that the proceedings were not vexatious.

The ruling concerns retrospective reclassification of the payments in this case. It does not prohibit corporations from choosing dividends in the first place or decide that every correction to a tax slip is impermissible. The court rejected the requested reclassification because it did not reflect what the company had actually done.