
A British Columbia charity failed to obtain an order preventing the Minister of National Revenue from publishing a notice revoking its registration while it pursued its objection and appeal rights.
In Central Organization for Jewish Education Lubavitch British Columbia v. Canada (National Revenue), 2026 FCA 179, the Federal Court of Appeal dismissed the interlocutory motion with costs on October 27, 2026. Justice Donald Rennie found that the organization had not established irreparable harm and that the balance of convenience did not favour an injunction.
The ruling did not finally decide whether revocation was justified. The judge expressly recognized that the alleged breaches of a compliance agreement had not been proven on the merits, and that the charity retained statutory routes to challenge the minister’s decision.
Repeated audits preceded the proposed revocation
The organization, referred to as Central in the reasons, had been audited several times since the mid-1980s. Earlier audits led to education letters and, following an audit covering 2011 to 2013, a compliance agreement in 2018.
That agreement required changes to donation receipting, gifts to entities that were not qualified donees, expenditure controls, reporting and records for donated artwork and other assets. It also addressed taxable-benefit reporting and approval of reimbursements to directors.
A later audit of the 2020 and 2021 taxation years identified further concerns, including some previously raised. In a May 2025 administrative fairness letter, the Canada Revenue Agency outlined alleged deficiencies in books and records, internal controls, charitable use of resources, receipting, information returns and qualification as a charitable organization.
Central disputed parts of the allegations and said its work advanced religious education and services, poverty relief and community benefit. It acknowledged record-keeping deficiencies during the audit period and described corrective steps, including new digital systems for payroll, expenses, bookkeeping and receipts, and changes to board composition.
The minister remained dissatisfied. A June 18, 2026 response described the alleged problems as serious and systemic and said earlier promised corrections had not been implemented. Central applied for injunctive relief in July. The minister agreed not to publish the revocation notice until this interlocutory motion was decided.
Evidence had to establish more than ordinary consequences
The court applied the familiar three-part injunction test: a serious issue to be tried, irreparable harm if relief were refused, and a balance of convenience favouring the applicant. All three requirements had to be met. Strong evidence on one could not cure a complete failure on another.
The minister conceded that there was a serious issue. The dispute centred on the other two requirements.
Central argued that loss of registration would jeopardize donations, existing religious and educational programming, welfare services and its reputation. The evidence showed that donations and grants supplied 82 per cent of annual income, that it had 43 full- and part-time staff on payroll, and that it operated with an accumulated deficit.
But the charity had not provided a complete picture of its finances, such as its current budget, cash-flow statements or future binding financial commitments. It also had not addressed whether stored artwork could be sold to cover a funding shortfall.
The judge emphasized that the ordinary consequences of losing registered status do not automatically establish irreparable harm. Otherwise, any charity facing revocation could defeat the minister’s statutory power simply by pointing to reduced donations and operational disruption. Particular evidence of harm that cannot adequately be compensated or otherwise cured was required.
The court considered the effects on people who depended on Central’s programs, not just the organization itself. However, the evidence did not establish the extent of summer-camp subsidization, and the judge distinguished an earlier case involving subsidized full-time schooling about to begin. The 2026 camp had already finished; Central could seek an expedited objection and appeal process concerning its position for the following summer.
Evidence about interruption of meal services and the resulting loss of social and religious support was also considered. The judge accepted the importance of those services but found the evidence did not demonstrate losses sufficiently widespread or permanent to meet the legal test. This was an assessment of the evidence and degree of harm in this case, not a ruling that beneficiaries’ interests can never justify relief.
Public enforcement interests also weighed against a delay
Even if irreparable harm had been shown, the court found that Central would fail on the balance of convenience.
The public interest included the CRA’s enforcement of the registration rules, protection of donors and taxpayers, and confidence that charities competing for donations comply with the law. The seriousness and breadth of the alleged failures to honour the compliance agreement weighed heavily against Central, although those allegations remained subject to determination on the merits.
The judge also found that the summer camp’s educational and religious benefits did not readily support a delay when the camp’s own practices were a significant part of the minister’s concerns.
The court also rejected the argument that the minister had to show an urgent need for revocation because the underlying audit was several years old. The burden on this motion remained with Central to justify the requested restraint.
The reasons specify no costs amount. Under the statutory scheme described by the court, revocation takes effect when the notice is published in the Canada Gazette. Dismissal of the motion is not itself proof that publication subsequently occurred. The decision refused temporary protection; it did not extinguish Central’s objection and appeal rights.



