Jennifer Schwitzer won $130,521 at trial for money and work she put into a short-term rental business in the Okanagan. Once the awards to her former business associate were counted, Schwitzer was owed $724. In Schwitzer v Little, the B.C. Court of Appeal left that result in place, including a $110,000 defamation award arising from a false complaint to Jillian Little’s employer.

Little, a mortgage advisor, arranged financing and made the down payments on two rental properties in Kelowna and Vernon. Schwitzer, a realtor, helped fund the venture, furnished and renovated the properties, managed bookings and dealt with guests. The women discussed how Schwitzer might acquire an ownership interest. An April 2021 agreement provided for repayment of her financial contribution if they could not agree on ownership terms. They never reached that agreement.

After a 19-day trial, the judge rejected Schwitzer’s claim to an interest in the properties. He awarded her $92,090 for funds advanced and $38,431 for her work. Little received amounts for Schwitzer’s occupancy of one property and for security expenses, along with $60,000 in general damages and $50,000 in punitive damages for defamation. Little and her company, Little J Vacations Inc., owed Schwitzer the balance.

The appeal turned in part on how the judge had valued Schwitzer’s labour. He considered both parties’ evidence about the work and the time it took, along with salary data for a property manager in B.C. Justice Francis, writing for a unanimous panel, found that the judge had applied the correct principles. A disagreement over the weight he gave the evidence gave the appeal court no basis to set a new fee.

On defamation, the trial judge had found that Schwitzer orchestrated a friend’s false complaint to Little’s employer to threaten her employment. The friend complained the day after a court removed notices of Schwitzer’s lawsuit from the properties’ titles. Schwitzer had texted him asking for a call shortly after the order. The appeal court held that the judge could draw the inference he did from their relationship, the timing and the message.

Schwitzer sought to introduce pleadings from Little’s wrongful dismissal suit in Alberta to challenge the finding that the complaint had significantly contributed to her dismissal. The pleadings recorded what the parties intended to prove. They contained no findings by the Alberta court about why Little lost her job. The panel refused to admit them. It also declined to entertain a new defence of qualified privilege because the trial judge’s finding of actual malice would have defeated it.

Schwitzer sought prejudgment interest on the full $130,521. Justice Francis said that the most she could claim interest on was the $724 the trial order required Little to pay. Given how little interest that could produce, the panel set the rate at zero. It also dismissed Schwitzer’s requests to vary two earlier appeal orders and refused to seal an affidavit. Sealing it against public access would still have left Little, the person whose access concerned Schwitzer, able to read it.

Read the full judgment in Schwitzer v Little, 2026 BCCA 440.