
The Manitoba Court of Appeal upheld three firearms convictions and refused permission to appeal a five-and-a-half-year sentence in R. v. Harder, 2026 MBCA 89. Reasons released November 5 explain the October 27 ruling.
Harder challenged findings that he fired the shots and that the weapon met the Criminal Code’s firearm definition, requiring capacity to cause serious injury or death. Two witnesses heard shots and then saw him holding a gun, but neither saw it fired. He admitted bringing out a gun while denying firing it.
The court found the inferences reasonably available on the evidence accepted at trial, with guilt the only reasonable conclusion. The absence of a seized weapon, forensic testing and expert evidence did not defeat the case: testimony, threats and surrounding circumstances supported the findings.
On sentence, the court found mitigating circumstances had received reasonable weight. Prior firearms convictions, a prohibition order and the spousal context supported high culpability. Harder showed no arguable error in principle or demonstrably unfit sentence.



