William Waters transferred more than $30 million over a decade to Gillian Henry, the personal support worker he had hired to care for his wife. When his estate sought to recover money and properties after his death, a trial judge found that most of the transfers were gifts. In Waters Estate v. Henry, the Court of Appeal for Ontario ordered a new trial on the disputed gifts. Among the evidence it said the judge had mishandled were notes Waters wrote to himself about properties bought with the money.

The transfers began in 2009. Some paid for cars, trips and other personal expenses. About $19 million went toward buying and renovating properties. Henry acknowledged that some advances were loans. She said Waters wanted to help her become a real estate investor. The estate maintained that he had kept a financial interest in the properties.

Henry bore the burden of showing, on a balance of probabilities, that Waters intended to make gifts. The trial judge had looked for proof that Waters expected repayment or retained an interest. Justice Pomerance, writing for the unanimous panel, said that approach put the burden on the estate. Henry herself acknowledged debts that Waters had never documented. And evidence that he intended to give her a personal item could not explain why he financed a property purchase.

The handwritten notes illustrated the problem. Some listed properties and dollar amounts. The trial judge excluded most of them as hearsay after finding inconsistencies between the entries and other evidence. The estate’s point was that the act of keeping those records could show that Waters was tracking investments. Whether the notes were admissible for that purpose, and how much weight they deserved, would be for the new trial judge to decide.

The panel also addressed the trial judge’s finding that Waters and Henry had an intimate relationship. Their relationship could help explain his generosity. On its own, however, it could not supply the independent evidence Ontario’s Evidence Act required to support Henry’s account of his intentions.

The estate did not challenge payments toward a Visa card Henry used. The new trial will address the disputed transfers, whether any claims were brought too late and the estate’s claim that Henry owed Waters a fiduciary duty. The panel upheld Waters’s 80 per cent beneficial interest in King of Hearts, a horse stable business. It also ordered Henry to pay the estate $1,938,000 traceable to his wife, Phyllis, and directed the estate to pay her promptly.

Read the Court of Appeal for Ontario’s reasons, 2026 ONCA 704.