
Tim Hortons boat-email class action refused by Quebec appeal court
The court held that an erroneous post-contest recap could not support the pleaded claim under Quebec’s consumer-contract conformity rules.
Section
Civil procedure, court process, pleadings, motions, evidence, remedies and appellate procedure across Canada.
255 stories
The court held that an erroneous post-contest recap could not support the pleaded claim under Quebec’s consumer-contract conformity rules.

Appeal judge refused to suspend five subpoenas concerning access to correctional-unit video, finding the public interest in a timely investigation outweighed the government’s case…

Nova Scotia court rejects broader affidavit and transcript demands while stressing the evidence needed to protect documents from disclosure.

Specialty Life wins recognition of arbitration awards against Daumier, while non-parties retain their defences and court costs remain unresolved.

The tribunal distinguished a pre-existing report requirement from settlement information, while finding the complainant’s reference to mediation improper.

Saskatchewan court enforces prepaid streaming contracts after missed deliveries, but leaves mortgage enforcement for a later application.

The interim ruling leaves the judicial review unresolved, accepts reputational harm despite weak evidence, and awards $5,000 in costs.

Federal appeal court upholds the CRA’s original-news assessment while distinguishing reporting practices from political viewpoint.

Federal Court finds new graphs were evidence, but the miner had a fair chance to respond in final-offer arbitration.

The Ontario ruling concerns fairness in an unfinished construction arbitration; actual bias was not alleged and the contractors’ claims remain unresolved.

Loan-default challenge belongs in provincial superior court, judge rules, leaving fairness and timeliness arguments undecided.

BC Hydro succeeds on a narrow remand after the judge finds lawyer-assisted reports reflected the expert’s own opinions.

Abi-Mansour’s rescission motion failed because it reargued the original designation rather than showing the protective order was no longer needed.

The court refused an interlocutory injunction over short-term rentals, finding the operators had not met the heightened evidence threshold; their lawsuit remains unresolved.

Court dismisses benefits appeal while criticizing how the mootness issue reached the Federal Court without a formal motion.

AussieFit and its owner must secure potential defence costs in two cases, but the court rejected requests totalling $87,167 as unfair.

Court finds financial harm could be compensated while leaving the merits of the customer’s appeal for another panel.

The court left access rights and road-building costs undecided, finding the requested declaration premature before the planning process.

The court held that Eckler’s advance coverage motion fell outside the CCAA proceeding’s purpose, while leaving the insurance merits and unappealed AIG findings untouched.

The Supreme Court ordered a direct transfer after finding that lease obligations formed part of the debt, distinct from ordinary court-awarded costs and interest.