
Manitoba court upholds school division’s withholding of records
Superior-to-staff communications can qualify as protected advice, judge finds.
Section
Court decisions, disputes and legal developments filed under Manitoba.
91 stories
Superior-to-staff communications can qualify as protected advice, judge finds.

The June 24 decision also imposes $5,000 in costs and extensive return-to-practice conditions after admitted registration, advertising and competence breaches.

Manitoba judge finds enforcement delay gave swine-breeding companies real value; freight forwarder fails to move its judgment ahead of the bank.

Sale proceeds must be held while an associate judge determines whether a surviving partner’s rights continue and what they are worth.

A Manitoba judge required a trial on the city’s role and whether Charter scrutiny applies, without deciding whether the 2014 advertising refusal violated any rights.

The Manitoba Labour Board found substantive defects in the association’s purposes, membership rules and independence, without deciding the employees’ eligibility to bargain.

Replacement request failed on the document’s wording.

Manitoba judge rejected shareholder meetings with defective notices and confirmed a five-member board that still included Benjamin Nasberg.

A Manitoba homeowner’s claim failed because he accepted an interruption lasting more than a year, even though he continued driving over part of the disputed strip.

Access protects the client’s interests, but does not open the files to opposing parties.

A photograph that could be viewed as inappropriate did not, without corroborating evidence, establish interference with a worker’s compensation claim.

A Manitoba judge awarded both paid and unpaid deposits plus damages, while rejecting the buyer’s misrepresentation counterclaim and preserving its separate claims against realtors.

Minty’s Moving can pursue contract rights, but paying money into court did not entitle it to a custom box under the garage-lien statute.

The Manitoba Labour Board found that shared management, administrative tasks and team-based patient care did not require a clinic-wide bargaining unit.

Detailed evidence of two businesses’ dependence on loading docks supported temporary protection, while competing lease interpretations remained for trial.

Lesley Selch was ordered to contribute $50,000 in costs after the panel found longstanding bullying and discriminatory conduct had persisted despite remediation.

Claims against the will-drafting lawyer and related defendants were dismissed, but the family’s challenge to the later will’s validity was left for trial.

A Manitoba judge discharged the landowner’s injunction after expropriation and weighed the protest’s public-interest dimension against the owner’s earlier court success.

Shared employment terms and financial arrangements outweighed the benefit of a separate summary debt proceeding.

The generating-station exemption did not cover local poles and power lines, but the subcontractor’s final entitlement remains for trial.