The Condominium Authority Tribunal of Ontario ordered a Peel business owner to comply with a September 2024 settlement over the use of shared loading areas and garbage bins. It gave him 30 days to pay the condominium corporation $11,150 in costs.

In Peel Standard Condominium Corporation No. 1002 v. Marshall, 2025 ONCAT 130, Member Mary Ann Spencer found that Sean Anthony Marshall stored wooden skids on the common elements, left vehicles and equipment in loading areas longer than necessary for loading or unloading, and put business waste in the corporation’s bins. She issued the order on August 8, 2025. Marshall operates a business from his unit in the commercial condominium at 6355 Kennedy Road in Mississauga.

All the outdoor space was shared. The settlement permitted Marshall to load and unload goods outside his own roll-up door. He also obtained his neighbour’s written permission to use its loading area on the same terms. Neither unit had a designated parking space behind it. When the corporation complained about a trailer outside the neighbouring unit, Marshall replied that he had permission to park there. Counsel reminded him that the permission lasted only as long as the loading or unloading reasonably required.

The timing of the photographs mattered. The corporation submitted 103 time-stamped images covering March 11 to 17, 2025. They showed skids stored continuously and a loaded trailer sitting for about seven hours on March 11 with no visible activity. Marshall supplied an April photograph showing his loading area clear. Photographs taken in July, while the case was underway, showed skids stacked there again.

Spencer declined to rely on a single April 30 photograph. The condominium manager said a large trailer had blocked garbage collection that day. Marshall said it was being loaded and he had stepped away briefly. A single image could not establish how long it had been parked. The manager also withdrew her evidence about a small blue trailer after Marshall disputed owning it.

Who put wood in the garbage bins posed a different question. Other businesses used similar skids, so photographs of debris in the bins did not identify who had put it there. Spencer also rejected the suggestion that Marshall had admitted a breach by saying he paid condo fees and others could use the bins. A March 13 video established the breach by showing him throw a piece of a broken skid into a bin.

Marshall argued that other owners received different treatment and suggested the corporation’s enforcement was discriminatory. Spencer accepted that photographs appeared to show other owners storing materials outside. They did not establish what enforcement action the corporation had taken. Marshall could have contested the original application, and the settlement acknowledged his opportunity to get independent legal advice before signing.

The settlement provided for full recovery of enforcement costs. The corporation sought $18,346.68 in legal fees and $150 in tribunal fees. Spencer exercised the discretion the tribunal’s rules gave her. The corporation had warned Marshall twice before filing, and the breaches continued during the proceeding. But the legal bill covered more than 40 hours in a largely uncontested case with one witness and no cross-examination. Vacation absences explained much of the elapsed time. Spencer awarded $11,000 in legal fees, about 60 per cent of the amount claimed for lawyers’ work, plus the $150 filing fees.

The order required immediate compliance. It limited parking to designated spaces or to either loading area for the time reasonably needed to load or unload goods. It also directed Marshall to stop storing property in the loading areas and putting business waste in the shared bins.

Read more about business cases in Canada.