Moira and Denis Holden built a deck beside their cabin at a recreational resort in Edgewater, B.C., knowing they needed written approval they did not have. In Valley’s Edge Park Ltd. v Holden, the B.C. Court of Appeal upheld a judge’s decision to leave the deck in place and order the Holdens to pay the resort administrator $5,000. The judge found that damages could enforce the building rules even though the owners had knowingly broken them.

The resort’s building scheme, registered against each strata lot, gave Valley’s Edge the power to approve improvements. The Holdens had obtained approval for work on a lot they owned previously. In 2022, after their relationship with the company’s president broke down, they took their plans to the elected strata council president. He told them the council lacked authority to approve the deck. By the time he passed the material to the company, the Holdens had finished building it.

Valley’s Edge gave the couple 30 days to remove the deck or submit complete plans. They sent a hand-drawn diagram. The company’s president considered the application incomplete and denied approval. The judge found that he had never identified what was missing or suggested changes that might satisfy him. The deck looked consistent with the cabin and surrounding resort. There was no evidence it interfered with anyone else’s use of their lot.

The administrator argued that letting the deck stand would encourage other owners to build first and seek permission later. Justice DeWitt-Van Oosten, writing for a unanimous panel, said the judge had recognized both that risk and the Holdens’ deliberate decision to proceed. An injunction is the usual remedy for a breach of a building scheme, but the judge could still consider what the owners had built, the effect on neighbours and whether damages would protect the community’s interests.

Valley’s Edge sought $20,000 in damages after the judge declined to order removal. The Holdens said they had spent $1,800 building the deck themselves and asked for nominal damages. The judge awarded $5,000. Neither side challenged the amount on appeal.

Both sides challenged the order for legal costs. Valley’s Edge wanted the Holdens to cover its entire legal bill. The building scheme allowed the administrator to recover the cost of work it arranged to correct a breach, but its wording was too vague to require owners to cover all the legal fees for seeking an injunction. The Holdens wanted each side to bear its own costs. The panel upheld the ordinary costs award to Valley’s Edge because it had established the breach and obtained damages.

For the appeals themselves, the panel awarded the Holdens costs for defending the company’s appeal and Valley’s Edge costs for defending the Holdens’ cross appeal. It directed that both be assessed at Scale A because both sides had made the proceeding more complex than necessary.

Read the B.C. Court of Appeal’s reasons, 2026 BCCA 447.