Quebec’s Court of Appeal has rejected a commercial condominium owner’s bid to claim exclusive use of a janitorial room and avoid contributing to the condominium syndicate’s legal fees, despite the owner’s partial success in recovering overpaid contributions at trial.

In Building Best Condos Inc. c. Syndicat de la copropriété Solar II, 2026 QCCA 1525, the court upheld the finding that space 006 was common property intended for janitorial services. It also upheld the owner’s obligation to pay its proportionate share of the syndicate’s professional fees as a common expense.

The November 11 decision leaves intact the trial judgment ordering the syndicate to reimburse Building Best $20,200 for contributions overpaid between 2019 and 2021. That partial victory did not establish that the syndicate had acted unreasonably in the wider dispute.

A janitorial room, not exclusive storage

The Superior Court had declared that space 006 was, and always had been, a common portion administered, or to be administered, by the syndicate under article 5 of the declaration of co-ownership. Building Best argued that it was instead a common portion for restricted use: storage reserved exclusively for the commercial unit.

The owner challenged the trial judge’s description of the declaration as an unnamed contract. It argued that the Civil Code of Québec governs declarations of co-ownership as a recognized contractual institution.

The appeal court found that classification irrelevant to the outcome. Nobody disputed that the Civil Code applied, but none of the provisions Building Best invoked changed the result. Whatever label attached to the declaration, the trial judge had correctly identified the interpretation framework established by the Supreme Court of Canada in Uniprix.

The decisive question was factual: did the room fall within the declaration’s provisions for storage spaces that the declarant could allocate, or was it the janitorial room designated as common property? Appellate intervention required a palpable and overriding error.

The declaration did not answer that question unambiguously. It referred to approximately 30 storage spaces, and a required plan identifying restricted-use storage spaces had never been prepared. Building Best acknowledged that omission, which contributed to the ambiguity.

The trial judge therefore examined the evidence as a whole. Space 006 was the only location suitable for janitorial services; the toilet space Building Best proposed as an alternative was manifestly inadequate. The owner’s interpretation would leave the building without the janitorial room that the developer, acting as declarant, had itself provided for in the declaration. The syndicate had not participated in drafting that provision.

The appeal court found no palpable and overriding error in that assessment.

Partial success did not excuse common expenses

Building Best also sought exemption from contributing to the syndicate’s legal fees, arguing that the syndicate had acted unreasonably. The court held that the professional fees were a common expense to which Building Best, as a co-owner, had to contribute proportionately under article 1064 of the Civil Code.

The owner’s recovery of $20,200 followed a judicial admission by the syndicate’s representative about the excess contributions for 2019 through 2021. But on the remaining matters, Building Best had advanced a position contrary to the declaration, and the syndicate had needed to sue to gain access to the janitorial room.

The court found no reviewable error in rejecting the requested exemption. It also rejected as manifestly ill-founded the owner’s allegation that the syndicate had abused the litigation process. Building Best had sought that finding for both the trial and appeal, together with a return to the trial court for an inquiry into the amount of legal fees.

Trial costs left unchanged

The syndicate, for its part, asked the appeal court to disturb the trial ruling that each side bear its own judicial costs. The court declined: that ruling was discretionary, and the syndicate had filed no cross-appeal.

Those judicial costs were distinct from the syndicate’s professional fees treated as common expenses. The appeal was dismissed with judicial costs on appeal. Building Best did not appeal the trial court’s separate refusal to set the contribution-allocation protocol applicable from 2022.

Source: Building Best Condos Inc. c. Syndicat de la copropriété Solar II, 2026 QCCA 1525.