
Quebec condo owner loses appeal over janitorial room and shared legal fees
A $20,200 refund for excess contributions did not exempt the owner from its proportionate share of the syndicate’s professional fees.
Section
Quebec Court of Appeal decisions and developments
8 stories
A $20,200 refund for excess contributions did not exempt the owner from its proportionate share of the syndicate’s professional fees.

The majority allowed reliance on the registered transfer, while a dissent required detrimental reliance; all three judges agreed that $12,595.23 should be returned to the owner.

The court held that an erroneous post-contest recap could not support the pleaded claim under Quebec’s consumer-contract conformity rules.

An earlier win over excessive cancellation fees did not give every member an immediately payable debt; individual claims still had to be decided.

Transport Martin Forget’s lowest bid should have won, but damages and causation remain for trial; its $300,000 claim was not awarded.

PG4's failure to follow the change-notice procedure did not defeat its claim after Énergir led it to expect the costs would be considered once the work was done.

The partial stay leaves the damages appeal and underlying findings undecided; only the requirement to publish parts of the judgment and a Haitian Creole translation was suspended.

Accurate inventory figures did not establish a deductible cause of loss; the company has applied for Supreme Court leave.