
Quebec’s Court of Appeal has restored a fuel-tax assessment of about $142,000 against a company operating Pétro-T service stations, ruling that accurate records of missing fuel did not, by themselves, establish a right to deduct the loss from tax remittances.
In Agence du revenu du Québec c. 189346 Canada inc., 2026 QCCA 1155, the court distinguished measuring a shortfall from explaining its cause. The company had to justify that the fuel was lost through evaporation, contraction, spillage or a similar cause recognized by the Fuel Tax Act. Its agreement to remit tax after resale did not exempt every quantity of fuel that it bought but did not sell.
The August 31 judgment reinstated an assessment covering October 2012 through January 2016, consisting of roughly $123,000 in tax and $19,000 in interest. The company has since applied for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada. The Supreme Court’s public docket acknowledged receipt of a complete application on November 3; it did not record a decision granting or refusing leave as of November 18.
Deferred collection was not a blanket exemption
Under an agreement dating from 1986, the company was permitted to buy fuel without first paying the tax and remit it when the fuel was resold. That arrangement differed from the ordinary retail system, in which retailers pay the tax on purchases and recover it from customers.
The dispute arose when the company adjusted its remittances for the difference between fuel acquired and fuel sold. During an audit, Revenu Québec requested explanations for the losses. The company supplied its calculations but did not justify the causes of the shortfalls covered by the disputed assessment.
The agreement expressly contemplated deductions for accidental spills supported by detailed claims. The company did not invoke that provision. The agency did allow separate relief involving a 17,201-litre delivery that had not been billed, but that item did not justify the other unexplained losses.
The Court of Québec had cancelled the assessment, accepting the company’s position on its reliable measurements and criticizing the agency’s method. The appeal court concluded that this approach overlooked the statutory conditions governing deductions.
Knowing how much was lost did not explain why
Sections 51 and 52 of the Fuel Tax Act required accounts of purchases, sales and use, and justification to the minister for losses attributed to the specified causes. The legislation did not impose a numerical ceiling on a properly justified qualifying loss. But it did require more than showing that the books contained a difference.
The accuracy of the company’s volume measurements was not the decisive issue. A precise calculation could establish the amount missing without showing that evaporation, contraction, spillage or a similar cause explained it.
The court illustrated the distinction by discussing other possible explanations for a shortfall. Those examples were not findings that the company had engaged in misconduct. Their point was that an unsold quantity did not automatically fit the statutory deduction.
The agreement also left the legislation applicable and required amendments to be in writing. Deferring tax collection until resale did not change the company’s obligation to account for fuel that disappeared from inventory.
Past practice did not change the law
The company relied on the agency’s previous acceptance of its approach, including the treatment of losses across its stations collectively. The court held that past administrative practice could not remove clear statutory requirements or amend the written agreement.
Revenu Québec nevertheless allowed a measure of loss without demanding further justification. Its administrative tolerance amounted to $33 per 100,000 litres of gasoline and $16.50 per 100,000 litres of diesel. These were monetary allowances in the calculation of tax, not a rule that every loss below a particular volume was legally exempt.
The gasoline allowance drew on the statutory compensation available to ordinary retailers for evaporation. The agency extended a smaller allowance to diesel even though the ordinary retail compensation did not cover it. That concession did not relieve the company of the obligation to justify additional losses.
Nor did the court accept that the agency had to combine the results of all stations. Each station had its own tanks and losses. Pooling them could allow smaller losses at one location to offset larger unexplained losses elsewhere. On this record, assessing the stations separately was reasonable.
The company had notice and opportunities to respond
The appeal court also rejected the procedural-fairness objection. An October 2016 audit email identified the statutory basis for the inquiry, asked for explanations of the losses and relevant events, and explained the station-by-station approach.
The company had further opportunities during the objection process and in court to support its claim. It still did not provide the required justification. The court concluded that it had not displaced the presumption that the assessment was valid.
The court separately confirmed that the Court of Québec had jurisdiction over the challenge to the assessment. There had been no ministerial decision on a properly supported loss claim to review, because no such justification had been provided. The appeal therefore did not require a ruling on the extent of that court’s accessory jurisdiction over discretionary ministerial decisions.
The appeal was allowed with legal costs, the company’s challenge was dismissed with legal costs, and the assessment was maintained. The judgment did not establish that the assessed amount had been collected. The pending leave application also means that the Supreme Court has not yet decided whether to hear the company’s proposed appeal.
Source: Agence du revenu du Québec c. 189346 Canada inc., 2026 QCCA 1155.



