
Quebec’s Court of Appeal has upheld a $133,424.58 damages award against a former estate liquidator and ordered her to pay another $25,000 after finding that her appeal was abusive.
In Succession de Borcar, 2026 QCCA 194, the court rejected Natasha Borcar’s challenges to findings about her administration of her father’s estate and her conduct after resigning. The January 12 decision distinguished a legitimate request for appellate scrutiny from an appeal whose arguments had no chance of success.
The additional award compensates the estate’s current liquidators for the abusive appeal. It is separate from the damages already awarded for losses to the estate, and from the legal costs of the appeal.
Estate losses, not every expense
The deceased was domiciled in Quebec when he died in 2016. His will left particular properties to his daughter and son and divided the remainder equally. Natasha Borcar served as liquidator from December 2016 until October 2018. Her brother and a notary subsequently replaced her.
The new liquidators sued in April 2021, claiming $513,812.56. Superior Court Justice Catherine Martel awarded only part of that amount in November 2024. The judgment was corrected the following month to fix two references to the year in which Natasha Borcar ceased acting as liquidator.
The trial findings included knowingly incomplete and misleading draft inventories, taking estate assets, inadequate accounting after resignation, unjustified bank withdrawals, and delays that increased the costs of selling properties. The judge also found fault in disposing of furniture without compensation and failing to deal diligently with the deceased’s credit-card account.
The appeal court emphasized that the trial judge had examined the claims cautiously and compensated only losses she found directly attributable to the former liquidator’s faults. The award did not make her responsible for every cost of administering a complex estate.
Two proceedings with different purposes
Natasha Borcar argued that the damages action duplicated an existing court proceeding in Joliette. That earlier file concerned administrative matters, including extensions of time for the successors to decide whether to accept the succession and the appointment of replacement liquidators.
The appeal court rejected the duplication argument, known as lis pendens. The proceedings had different objects: estate administration in one, and damages against the former liquidator in the other. Independently, the objection had been raised only during closing arguments at trial, years after the time for raising it had expired.
Her argument about Indian law also failed. Indian law might be relevant to some questions involving the estate’s immovable property there, the court acknowledged. But this case concerned damages for incompetent or dishonest administration, rather than the devolution of that property itself.
The argument was again raised only in closing, and no evidence of Indian law had been introduced. In those circumstances, the trial judge properly applied Quebec law. The decision did not establish that foreign law could never matter to an estate with property abroad.
Limits the appeal overlooked
The court rejected several challenges because they did not accurately reflect the judgment under appeal. The trial judge had not imposed the higher standard applicable to a professional liquidator, and had distinguished acts performed as liquidator from later acts in a personal capacity. She had not awarded damages for faults committed as the brother’s mandatary.
The inventory finding concerned knowingly misleading drafts concealing assets, not simply lateness in producing an inventory. Likewise, the former liquidator was required to reimburse only her own legal fees incurred for personal benefit, and only the replacement liquidators’ fees caused by her behaviour.
For the condominium sale, liability covered estate expenses beginning one year after she began acting as liquidator. For the Indian property, the judge attributed only part of the delay to her faults. Exchange-rate damages were confined to an actual loss on the portion of the sale proceeds converted into Canadian dollars.
These distinctions mattered to both the merits of the appeal and the later abuse finding. The court also noted that Natasha Borcar had not supplied the trial transcript, making her challenges to factual findings difficult, if not impossible, to adjudicate.
Why the court awarded another $25,000
The court applied the test of whether a reasonable and prudent person in the appellant’s position would have understood that the appeal had no chance of succeeding.
It found that threshold met. Natasha Borcar repeated the late procedural and foreign-law arguments, attacked findings the trial judge had not made, and challenged factual determinations without identifying a palpable and overriding error. The court also referred to her decision not to testify to explain her conduct at trial and her failure to file the transcript on appeal.
The replacement liquidators submitted invoices totalling $53,982.94 and sought $65,000 to include preparation for and argument of the appeal. The court awarded substantially less. Some of the claim overlapped with legal costs. The liquidators also had not moved to dismiss the appeal, a step the court considered likely to have succeeded and avoided some fees.
Exercising its discretion, the court fixed abuse damages at $25,000, in addition to appeal costs. The amount carries legal interest and the additional indemnity under article 1619 of the Civil Code of Québec from the date of the appeal judgment. The ruling confirms the awards; it does not establish that payment has been made.
Read the full decision on CanLII.



