
A New Brunswick judge has refused to let a plaintiff add aggravated and punitive damages to a defamation claim at the outset of trial, finding both unfair prejudice to the defendants and a failure to plead the material facts needed to support the new relief.
In Fraser v. Campey, MacEachern, Peoples Park Tower Senior’s Club and Hebert, 2026 NBKB 4, Justice Maya Hamou denied leave to file a further amended claim and ordered Lena Fraser to pay the defendants $1,000 in costs. The January 13 ruling decides the amendment motion, not whether the statements at issue were defamatory.
Fraser’s action concerned 13 allegedly defamatory statements made during two meetings of a seniors’ club in 2024. She sued the club and several individuals associated with it. The defendants disputed the proposed expansion of the case after preparing their evidence in response to the existing claim for general damages.
A July motion and a new paragraph at trial
Fraser began the action under Rule 79 in September 2024 and amended it that December to add a defendant. On July 21, 2025, she filed a motion seeking another amendment: removing requests for a public apology and retraction and for an order undoing the revocation of her club membership, while adding aggravated and punitive damages.
Before that motion was heard, the action was set down for trial. At Fraser’s request, the motion was scheduled for the outset of the trial on January 12, 2026. During argument that day, her lawyer supplied a new version containing an additional paragraph alleging that the statements knowingly misrepresented the facts, sought to justify the membership decision and were maliciously intended to harm her.
Her lawyer explained that the proposed change followed a review of the defendants’ affidavits and the perceived absence of evidence supporting their statements. Fraser maintained that the procedural rules permitted that approach. The defendants did not oppose deleting the two remedies, but opposed the additional damages claim and the new allegations.
Why timing caused unfair prejudice
The court acknowledged the generally liberal approach to amendments. Rule 27.10 permits amendments at any stage unless they cause prejudice that costs or an adjournment cannot compensate, and amendments needed to determine the real questions in dispute should be allowed. But proposed pleadings must still comply with the requirement to state material facts.
Hamou identified two distinct problems. The first was the effect of changing the case after the evidence had been submitted under Rule 79, which requires an exchange of affidavit evidence before the matter is set down for trial.
The defendants had prepared their evidence to answer the existing claim. The proposed changes required them to respond to allegations of high-handed, malicious, arbitrary or reprehensible conduct without having had the opportunity to address them before trial. The prejudice was compounded by leaving the earlier motion unheard until trial and introducing a further paragraph during the hearing.
Given Rule 79’s deadlines and procedural constraints, defendants needed to understand the case before tendering their evidence. Hamou found no reasonable explanation for the late changes and concluded that forcing them to start again minutes before trial would be greatly unfair. She found prejudice that could not be compensated by costs, and questioned why trial had been scheduled while a pretrial procedure remained unfinished.
Allegations needed supporting facts
The second problem was independent of timing. Adding a paragraph alleging malice did not supply the underlying facts necessary to support the requested damages.
For punitive damages, the court relied on the Supreme Court of Canada’s explanation in Whiten v. Pilot Insurance Co. that punishment is exceptional and requires particularized pleading so a defendant understands the jeopardy and can respond. Describing conduct as malicious or reprehensible states a conclusion; it does not explain the facts said to justify punishment.
Aggravated damages serve a different purpose. The court referred to Hill v. Church of Scientology of Toronto, which recognizes compensation for increased humiliation and anxiety caused by particularly high-handed or oppressive conduct in a defamation case.
Hamou found that neither requested form of relief was supported by the necessary material facts in the proposed claim. The new paragraph supplied conclusory adjectives rather than explanatory facts. That deficiency provided a separate reason to refuse the amendment, apart from the prejudice arising from its timing and the Rule 79 process.
The motion was denied with $1,000 in costs. The decision does not resolve the truth of the disputed statements, establish malicious conduct by the defendants or determine damages on Fraser’s existing defamation claim.
Source: Fraser v. Campey, MacEachern, Peoples Park Tower Senior’s Club and Hebert, 2026 NBKB 4.



