
The Supreme Court of Yukon adjourned a civil jury request over allegedly undisclosed home defects. In Lavoie v Ewert, 2026 YKSC 8, decided February 10, 2026, the court left the trial format for the case management judge to decide.
Chief Justice Duncan explained that applicants must first meet the Jury Act’s eligibility, timing and security requirements. The opposing party then bears the burden of showing that reviewing extensive documents or accounts, or conducting a scientific inquiry, would be impractical for a jury. The court may also intervene on its own.
Defence expert reports were outstanding and discovery was incomplete. A related insurance action raised the same question about the home’s condition. Separate trials risked conflicting findings. A joint hearing could alter the evidence and let insurers address the jury request. With no trial dates set, the court saw little prejudice in waiting.
Neither the jury request nor liability was decided.



