Canadian Pacific Kansas City Railway has lost a judicial review challenge to an unjust-dismissal decision after the Federal Court of Appeal rejected procedural fairness arguments the railway had not raised with the labour board.

In Canadian Pacific Railway Company (Canadian Pacific Kansas City Railway) v. Katz, 2026 FCA 42, the court upheld the Canada Industrial Relations Board’s decision that William Katz was an employee rather than a manager and had been constructively dismissed. The February 25 judgment dismissed the application while reserving the court’s right to award costs.

Manager status determined access to statutory protection

Katz complained after changes to his employment terms and conditions. Whether he was a manager mattered because managers are excluded from the Canada Labour Code’s unjust-dismissal protections.

The board warned the parties in February 2024 that it could decide the complaint on the written record and directed them to provide complete information and relevant documents. Katz submitted particulars in March, CPKC responded in April, and Katz replied through two letters in May.

CPKC argued in its response that Katz was a manager and expressly asked for the complaint to be dismissed without a hearing. The board ultimately rejected the railway’s position in its July 3, 2025 decision.

No request to change procedure or file further evidence

On judicial review, CPKC argued that the absence of an oral hearing was unfair and that Katz’s reply introduced new arguments about his status which the railway had no meaningful opportunity to answer.

The appeal court noted that section 16.1 of the Code gives the board discretion to decide matters without an oral hearing. More importantly for this case, CPKC itself had requested that procedure and the record did not show it later withdrew that position.

The railway also never asked to file additional submissions or documents after Katz’s reply. The court said an employer would already know its employee’s responsibilities. Having raised manager status as a reason to exclude the complaint, CPKC bore the burden of establishing it, yet its response supplied few details and cited no case law.

The board’s June 4, 2024 letter said the submission process was complete and no further submissions were requested. The court distinguished that statement from a prohibition on asking for permission to provide more material. More than a year passed before the board decided the matter, leaving ample opportunity for CPKC to raise a concern.

Objections must be raised when they can be addressed

The court applied the established principle that a party must raise an alleged procedural violation at the earliest practical opportunity. It cannot wait for an adverse result before objecting to a procedure it could have challenged earlier.

There was no unfairness in failing to grant an additional opportunity that CPKC never requested. The railway’s brief challenge to the reasonableness of the finding that Katz was not a manager also disclosed no basis for intervention.

The judgment leaves the board’s decision intact but does not quantify compensation or fix costs. It illustrates the importance of supplying the necessary evidence and seeking procedural relief during the administrative proceeding, rather than assuming judicial review will provide a new opportunity afterward.