Ventum Financial Corp. can pursue records about its former clients while an investment adviser and his new firm prepare a challenge to his non-compete clause. In Ventum Financial Corp. v Woods, the B.C. Supreme Court refused to split liability from damages or put discovery about damages on hold. The same client records could help establish both whether business was improperly diverted and what the investment dealer lost.

Jeffery Woods joined the Victoria office of PI Financial Corp., later renamed Ventum, in 2016. His employment letter contained no post-employment non-compete. The restriction at issue came from a November 2021 agreement under which a retiring adviser transferred management of his client accounts to Woods. For two years from the agreement’s effective date, Woods was to work as an investment adviser, or in a comparable role, only for PI Financial.

Ventum alleges Woods left in January 2023 and joined another investment dealer, Leede Financial Inc., five days later. It sued Woods in May 2023 and later added Leede. Ventum alleges that Woods breached his employment obligations and that the defendants conspired to solicit clients, misused confidential information and received funds diverted from client accounts. The November 13 ruling decided how the case could proceed. The allegations and the enforceability of the restriction remain unresolved.

Why the records matter to both sides of the case

Woods and Leede argued that if the non-compete proved unenforceable, most or all of Ventum’s case would fall away. They also argued that an early ruling could encourage settlement. They wanted all questions of liability decided before the court turned to damages. Ventum identified the alleged conspiracy as the heart of its case. It said that claim could proceed even if Woods was free to work for a competitor.

Associate Judge Vos explained that a party can seek a summary ruling on an issue without the court’s permission. Requiring one set of issues to be tried before the rest takes a discretionary order. The question was whether splitting this case would save time and money while allowing a fair decision on each issue.

Correspondence with former clients could show whether the defendants used confidential information. Transaction records could reveal whether money moved from client accounts and help establish the amount of any loss. A liability hearing could therefore require much of the evidence needed at a damages hearing. Hearing it twice would add cost and risk inconsistent findings. The defendants had shown neither that deciding the non-compete issue would resolve the other claims nor that it would materially improve the prospects of a settlement. The evidence about the parties’ relative financial resources gave the judge no reason to split the trial.

An open-ended pause in discovery

The defendants also sought to postpone document disclosure and questioning about damages until the court ruled on the clause. The parties had exchanged document lists, but Ventum had asked for additional records and no examinations for discovery had taken place. At the hearing, the defendants had neither served a summary application nor reserved a hearing date. Their counsel expected to conduct more discovery before serving the application.

That would leave Ventum waiting for a step whose timing its opponents controlled. Even if the defendants succeeded on the clause, Ventum would still need records of their dealings with former clients to investigate the alleged conspiracy. The judge declined to restrict discovery on the strength of a motion the parties and the court had yet to see.

Woods and Leede remained free to seek a summary ruling on the non-compete. The judge said Ventum would be entitled to its costs of opposing the applications unless a party filed written submissions seeking a different order within 14 days of the reasons.

Read the B.C. Supreme Court’s reasons, 2026 BCSC 2197.