
Fourteen SGS Canada grain inspectors and graders in Montréal fall under federal labour jurisdiction, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled, leaving Quebec’s labour tribunal without authority to certify their proposed bargaining unit under provincial law.
The 5–4 decision in Quebec (Attorney General) v. SGS Canada inc., 2026 SCC 37, released November 6, dismissed Quebec’s appeal with costs. The majority found the employees’ work sufficiently integrated with federally regulated grain elevators, even though SGS neither owns nor operates those facilities.
Justice Andromache Karakatsanis wrote for the majority. Justice Nicholas Kasirer, joined by Chief Justice Richard Wagner and Justices Suzanne Côté and Michelle O’Bonsawin, dissented. The disagreement concerned how far federal authority can extend beyond a regulated facility to an independent contractor serving it.
The ruling determines which government’s labour regime applies to this group. It does not certify a union or decide the merits of the workers’ request for representation.
A certification application became a constitutional dispute
The Syndicat des travailleuses et travailleurs des industries manufacturières – CSN sought certification under Quebec’s Labour Code to represent inspectors and graders in SGS’s Montréal branch. The Administrative Labour Tribunal dismissed the application for lack of provincial jurisdiction. The Superior Court and Court of Appeal upheld that result, although their reasoning differed.
SGS provides testing, inspection and certification services across many industries. Its Montréal agriculture branch devotes about 90 per cent of its work to six grain elevators along the St. Lawrence River. Its largest client is Viterra, which operates the Montréal terminal.
The inspectors collect samples, test grain and check whether storage facilities are clean. Graders assess characteristics affecting grain quality and price. Much of their work takes place in laboratories at the elevators, with frequent testing and communication as grain is loaded.
The facilities are federal works because Parliament has declared grain elevators to be for Canada’s general advantage under the Constitution’s declaratory power and the Canada Grain Act. Labour relations ordinarily fall within provincial authority, so SGS still had to establish a basis for treating these employees as an exception.
The branch could be assessed separately
Quebec argued that the lower bodies had not adequately justified separating the Montréal employees from SGS’s broader business. It said neither the company as a whole nor its national agriculture division had the required integration with Viterra.
The majority treated identification of the relevant operation as the first step. A court can examine a distinct unit within a larger business, but cannot artificially divide an integrated operation simply to change its constitutional classification.
Here, Karakatsanis found the branch sufficiently separate. Its specialized employees served Quebec grain elevators, had little operational connection with other branches and worked under largely independent local management. Other branches performed a wider range of agricultural testing. Shared central functions such as payroll did not defeat the evidence of a distinct operation.
The inquiry turns on actual functions, not corporate labels or geography alone. The majority acknowledged that the tribunal had not expressly found the branch divisible, but held its factual findings supported that conclusion.
Important services did not make SGS an elevator operator
The majority agreed with Quebec on one point: the Court of Appeal had incorrectly applied direct federal jurisdiction. That route concerns employees of an entity that owns, manages, controls or otherwise operates a federal work or undertaking.
SGS was an outside inspection provider. Its clients operated the elevators, and there was no evidence that SGS and those operators shared management or formed a single enterprise. The importance of its services did not turn SGS into an operator.
The result nevertheless survived under derivative federal jurisdiction. That route asks both whether the contractor’s services are essential to the federal operation and whether serving that operation forms the principal part of the contractor’s own activities. A temporary connection or a minor assignment does not suffice.
Why the majority found sufficient integration
The majority relied on evidence that grain could not move through Viterra’s terminal without the branch’s inspection services. Regular testing allowed operators to correct loading when grain failed to meet specifications. SGS’s work also helped prevent costly problems with export shipments, while the Canadian Grain Commission remained responsible for official export certification.
The branch’s employees worked on Viterra’s premises and communicated frequently with the operator. The majority found Viterra’s business predominant in the branch’s operations. More broadly, about 90 per cent of the branch’s work served the six federally regulated elevators.
Karakatsanis rejected the proposition that integration must be proved with only one federal business. A contractor can qualify through its relationship with several identifiable federal works or undertakings, provided the evidence establishes the required connections. The majority rejected the contrary single-undertaking requirement in the Quebec Court of Appeal’s Madysta Télécom decision.
Nor did the Court impose a fixed percentage of work needed to qualify. Predominance remains a demanding, fact-specific requirement, rather than an automatic numerical threshold.
Four judges saw an unwarranted extension of federal power
Kasirer agreed that SGS did not fall under direct federal jurisdiction. He also accepted that its services were important to Viterra, but considered importance insufficient to establish the close mutual dependence needed for derivative jurisdiction.
The dissent emphasized SGS’s independent role in verifying grain quality for commercial transactions. Viterra’s business included buying and selling grain as well as operating an elevator. Kasirer would have required clearer separation of services supporting the federally declared facility from services meeting broader commercial needs.
He also rejected combining work for six rival elevator operators into a single measure of integration. In his view, the evidence did not establish what proportion of the branch’s work served Viterra. Being the largest client was not enough to prove the necessary predominance.
The judges differed on the branch’s separate status too. For Kasirer, a unit’s separation from the broader provincial business had to emerge from its integration with a particular federal undertaking, rather than being settled as a preliminary question.
The majority took a different view of both the evidence and the framework. It found elevator operations and the related grain dealings closely intertwined, and concluded the branch’s sustained, predominant work for the federal facilities met the constitutional test.
The dismissal leaves the provincial certification application rejected for lack of jurisdiction. The decision does not place every SGS employee, every grain-industry contractor or every business with a federal client under federal labour law.
Source: Supreme Court of Canada judgment.



