
In a March 25, 2026 decision, Newfoundland and Labrador planning adjudicator Garreth McGrath upheld Portugal Cove–St. Philip’s rescission of Ian Gosse’s conditional fence approval. See the Appeal 15-006-094-002.
Council initially approved the proposal subject to provincial authorization concerning alteration of a water body. Gosse obtained that approval, but council then received further information and withdrew its conditional authorization on March 25, 2025, before final approval.
Gosse argued that similar fences existed nearby and that he had already incurred the cost of satisfying the provincial condition.
McGrath found that the town’s development regulations expressly left conditional approvals subject to further council approval. Council had relied on new information about site suitability and possible stormwater problems when exercising its discretion.
The adjudicator explained that he could not simply replace council’s discretionary judgment with his own. Intervention remained possible for decisions contrary to planning legislation or regulations, or breaching natural justice, but no such basis was established here.
The appeal was dismissed. The decision did not authorize construction of the proposed fence.



