Arbitrator James C. Oakley, K.C., ordered Iron Ore Company of Canada to reinstate a drill operator effective from the Jan. 17, 2025 discharge date, with full redress subject to a three-day suspension for disrespectful behaviour. The May 7, 2026 award in United Steelworkers Local 5795 v Iron Ore Company of Canada, 2026 CanLII 96397 (NL LA) allowed the grievance in part.

IOC had relied on two alleged infractions: reporting to work and operating a vehicle under the influence of drugs, and disrespect towards a supervisor. Oakley found the drug-test result inadmissible because the employer had not established reasonable cause to test. The drug-related infraction was therefore unproven, while the disrespectful conduct was established. The award was not a complete exoneration, and compensation remained governed by the collective agreement’s terms.

Dispute began at a safety meeting

The employee had about 16 years of service, including about 14 years as a driller, and worked 12-hour shifts. The parties agreed that both the job and the mine were safety-sensitive. The discharge followed events at a Jan. 4, 2025 toolbox meeting, against the background of a disagreement the previous day about radio communication and permission to enter drill areas.

The employee complained of harassment over radio procedures and said they would not return to the same drill assignment. The supervisor described a rude response, raised voice, aggressive gestures and a demand about the assignment. The employee denied being disrespectful. Another crew member did not hear disrespectful comments but acknowledged being unable to hear everything said across the room.

IOC argued that the trained supervisor’s observations justified testing and that the screening result, together with expert evidence, established unfitness for duty. It acknowledged that the delay in arranging testing was not best practice, but said a new supervisor had sought guidance before acting. The union disputed both the alleged misconduct and the testing grounds, challenged the checklist process and argued that the absence of a laboratory confirmation undermined the employer’s proof.

Disrespect was proved

Oakley preferred the supervisor’s account of the meeting. It was detailed and consistent with contemporaneous reporting to management. He found that the employee made a rude comment about the supervisor not listening to the radio, demanded a different assignment, spoke in a raised voice and waved their arms aggressively. That conduct violated IOC’s Respect, Inclusion and Diversity Policy.

The supervisor had not provoked or aggravated the employee. The directions about radio communication followed an earlier safety incident. Oakley also rejected the contention that the supervisor simply ignored the harassment concern: the supervisor offered a private discussion after the meeting, which the employee declined. There was just cause for discipline on this ground.

Testing required more than the misconduct finding

The separate question was whether IOC could rely on the drug-test result. Section 4.3.4 of its Substance Abuse Prevention Policy required observations by a trained supervisor or official forming a reasonable basis to suspect non-compliance. Oakley treated compliance with the policy and legal requirements for workplace testing as a prerequisite to reliance on the result, balancing workplace safety against employee privacy and bodily integrity.

The reasonable-cause checklist rested on the supervisor’s observations at the meeting, not observations of the employee performing work or a fresh assessment at the office. It recorded behavioural indicators of irritability, hostility, belligerence and irrationality, but no physical indicators. A second supervisor signed as verifier without making independent observations supporting the testing decision.

Oakley rejected a categorical rule that the verifier had to observe the employee independently. The policy allowed circumstances in which only one person witnessed the relevant behaviour and another verified that the checklist accurately recorded it. But the absence of independent observations remained relevant when deciding whether reasonable cause actually existed on this record.

The employer had also failed to consider other possible explanations for the behaviour before deciding to test. The employee believed they had been harassed over radio communication and wanted another assignment to avoid the co-worker involved. Oakley did not find that this justified the disrespect or establish that harassment occurred. His point was that the employer had not investigated the perceived harassment as a possible explanation other than drug influence.

The timing mattered too. After the meeting, the employee was allowed to proceed to work and drove a company pickup carrying two colleagues to their locations. The employee did not operate the drill because it lacked power. About three hours passed before the shop steward was asked to bring the employee in for testing. IOC had also considered testing the previous day, but took no related action before allowing the employee to return and proceed to the drill on Jan. 4.

Oakley considered that sequence inconsistent with the claimed grounds for testing. He distinguished a transit arbitration in which supervisors let an employee drive home only after completing a test. Here, permission to proceed into the mine preceded the reasonable-cause decision. The timing was one factor in the assessment, not a rule that every testing delay invalidates a test.

Taken together, the evidence did not establish reasonable cause. IOC had not complied with its policy, so the result could not be considered in deciding whether the employee was under the influence of drugs. Without that result, the employer had not proved the drug-related infraction. The ruling did not impose a general ban on reasonable-cause testing.

Laboratory and expert-evidence questions left open

The oral-fluid screening test produced a non-negative result but no concentration measurement. A further sample was damaged in transit, leaving no laboratory confirmation. The employer’s expert qualified the opinion on fitness for duty because that confirmation was unavailable.

Oakley expressly declined to decide whether the screening result and expert testimony, taken together, would otherwise have established that the employee was under the influence. The decisive problem was the lack of reasonable cause and resulting inadmissibility, not a finding that the screening result was inaccurate or that the employee was drug-free.

Three-day penalty and compensation limits

Disrespect alone did not justify discharge in these circumstances. Oakley weighed the insubordinate demand, absence of provocation and lack of regret or remorse against approximately 16 years of service and no evidence of a disciplinary record. He substituted a three-day suspension rather than removing discipline altogether.

Article 10.06 authorized substitution of a suspension for discharge and addressed compensation. It provided for wages at the regular basic rate for time lost outside the suspension, less amounts earned during that time. Recovery was limited to the scheduled work week and a maximum of 180 scheduled eight-hour workdays or 120 scheduled 12-hour workdays, with days added for arbitration delay requested by the company and days deducted for delay requested by the union.

The award did not calculate a dollar amount. The parties had agreed that Oakley would remain seized of interpretation or compensation issues, with notice to him within 60 days following publication of the award. The order establishes reinstatement and redress obligations; it does not establish that reinstatement or payment has since occurred.