
Newfoundland and Labrador planning adjudicator Clifford Johnston upheld Paradise’s refusal of a subsidiary apartment in a May 11, 2026 decision on Paul Marsh’s appeal for DMP Contracting. See the Appeal 15-006-094-010.
The town initially issued a permit for a house with an apartment, then acknowledged that approval was erroneous and replaced it with permission for the house alone. Construction had substantially advanced under the original permit.
The homeowners said they relied on the permit and expected rental income. Marsh also cited nearby apartments, parking capacity and affordable-housing demand.
However, subsidiary apartments were discretionary uses in the residential low-density zone. The town subsequently advertised the application, received thirteen objections and refused it through council.
Johnston found the required procedures had been followed. The regulations allowed revocation of permits issued in error and gave council discretion to approve or refuse the apartment application. The adjudicator could not substitute his decision for a lawful discretionary choice.
The order confirmed council’s June 10, 2025 refusal; it did not determine compensation for reliance on the mistaken permit.



