
Yukon’s chief justice has rejected a request to step aside from a litigant’s applications for permission to start new proceedings, finding that disputed case-management decisions and court-registry communications did not establish a reasonable apprehension of bias.
Chief Justice Duncan dismissed Juanita Wood’s recusal application after considering her concerns both individually and together. The judge found that the challenged procedural order had protected Wood’s ability to bring a proposed claim while the court addressed restrictions on her litigation.
The August 14 decision, Wood v Yukon (Government of), 2026 YKSC 70, concerns who would hear the leave applications. It does not decide whether those proposed proceedings should be allowed to go ahead.
Urgent filing concern led to case management
Wood had been declared a vexatious litigant in 2018, a finding upheld on appeal, following proceedings connected to the end of her government employment. In March 2026, she sought to rescind that order so she could bring a new claim against the workers’ compensation board.
She asked for an urgent hearing, saying a limitation period would expire in early April. Government counsel proposed allowing her to file the new claim provisionally while the rescission application proceeded on a workable schedule.
At a March 31 case-management conference, Duncan adopted that approach and directed that the rescission application be treated as a petition in a new court file, rather than remain in a discontinued proceeding.
Wood argued that the judge’s agreement with government counsel, short notice, procedural changes, lack of written reasons and failure to explain consequences to her showed unfairness. She later withdrew the converted petition and filed seven applications for leave to institute proceedings, together with the recusal request.
Procedural disagreement did not establish bias
The court applied an objective test: whether a reasonable, informed person, considering the circumstances practically, would conclude that the judge was more likely than not to decide unfairly. Judicial impartiality is presumed, and the party alleging bias must establish serious grounds.
Duncan found that the short-notice conference responded to Wood’s own urgent request. Provisionally accepting her claim protected her stated limitation concern without deciding whether she could proceed. Converting the rescission request to a petition did not change its substance, require her to refile or increase her exposure to costs.
Agreeing with a party’s procedural proposal did not, by itself, show partiality. The court had broad case-management powers and could resolve procedural issues without a separate formal application for every direction.
The conference had also taken place on the record. Its recording, transcript and the parties’ earlier correspondence provided accountability even though no separate written reasons followed the routine procedural order.
Registry and publication concerns also rejected
Wood also alleged inappropriate judicial intervention in the registry’s handling of her documents and one-sided communications. Duncan rejected her assumptions about the judge’s involvement. Both parties had received the emails forwarded to the judge, and judicial guidance to registry staff about unusual filings was not inherently improper.
A memorandum explaining a filing deficiency was appropriate, the judge found. Duncan said it had not been brought separately to her attention and she first saw it when reviewing Wood’s affidavit for the hearing.
Wood further argued that the judge’s decision not to publish a December 2022 endorsement supported her bias concerns. Duncan explained that she had considered its unusual facts unlikely to assist other cases, but had since published it to address Wood’s concern.
The court agreed that Wood did not need separate permission to bring this recusal application. It also held that the Attorney General could make opposing submissions on it, while leaving the extent of that participation in the underlying leave applications for later consideration.
Viewed cumulatively and in context, the concerns did not meet the bias test. The recusal application was dismissed.



