In Ferhat Durmus and Heval Donair Inc., a Saskatchewan employment adjudicator upheld a $26,727.10 wage assessment against Heval Donair Inc., rejecting its argument that a restaurant employee performed managerial work excluded from overtime protections.

Adjudicator Clifford B. Wheatley denied the employer’s appeal after finding that Ferhat Durmus did not supervise, discipline, evaluate, hire or promote other employees. His limited independence in deciding when to cook or clean did not establish that he was a manager under the Saskatchewan Employment Act.

The decision in Labour Relations Board file 010-26 was signed on September 16, 2026. The board’s public index lists September 17, the date stamped as received on the reasons.

Employer relied on a director’s declaration

Heval Donair, operating as Turkish Express-Donair Kebab Restaurant, maintained that Durmus was a manager. Although the employer did not attend the August 18 hearing in Regina, it was represented by a lawyer and asked that the hearing proceed using a statutory declaration from its corporate director.

The lawyer said the employer would not call other witnesses because those it had intended to call were unwilling to participate. The other parties agreed to proceed on that basis. Durmus attended, gave sworn evidence and was cross-examined.

Durmus testified that he worked at the restaurant from August 2022 to June 2024, from 10 a.m. to 10 p.m., six days a week. The employment standards officer said her audit used 12-hour days and a six-day workweek to calculate the wage assessment.

The officer also identified inconsistencies between T4 slips and an exhibit attached to the employer’s evidence, and said the earnings statement supplied by the employer did not meet statutory requirements. The adjudicator’s analysis focused on whether Durmus qualified for the managerial exemption.

Actual duties determined the exemption

Wheatley said the overtime exclusion applied to employees whose services were entirely managerial. Determining whether Durmus fell within it required examining the evidence about the work he actually performed.

The reasons drew on earlier cases requiring employment-standard exemptions to be interpreted strictly and describing managerial work as continuous, rather than occasional. They identified several relevant factors, including supervision, discipline, hiring, discretion, remuneration and involvement in budgets.

Those factors were not an exhaustive checklist, and they did not all have to be present or carry equal weight. The reasons placed particular importance on supervising workers and having the right to discipline them.

Durmus said he taught other employees to prepare dishes that had been added to the menu, at the employer’s request. But Wheatley found that he did not supervise or discipline employees, assess their performance, hire or promote staff, or participate in the employer’s budgets and performance requirements.

The adjudicator acknowledged Durmus’s discretion over cooking and cleaning. He also noted that Durmus had unsuccessfully tried to negotiate his pay, while there was no evidence establishing how his remuneration compared with that of other staff.

Applying the exemption narrowly, Wheatley found that Durmus was not a manager and left the existing $26,727.10 wage assessment in place. The decision’s closing notice identifies a right to appeal to the labour board on a question of law; the ruling does not establish that the assessment has been paid.

Read the adjudicator’s decision.